Used and loved by millions
Since I tried Ludwig back in 2017, I have been constantly using it in both editing and translation. Ever since, I suggest it to my translators at ProSciEditing.

Justyna Jupowicz-Kozak
CEO of Professional Science Editing for Scientists @ prosciediting.com
which constituted in
Grammar usage guide and real-world examplesUSAGE SUMMARY
The phrase "which constituted in" is not correct in standard written English.
It is not typically used, as "constituted" does not pair with "in" in this context. Example: "The committee was formed, which constituted the new board of directors."
⚠ May contain grammatical issues
Science
News & Media
Alternative expressions(20)
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Human-verified examples from authoritative sources
Exact Expressions
1 human-written examples
Producers compressed seven months of tedium and turmoil (including the corrosion of Bill and Pat's marriage) into twelve one-hour episodes, which constituted, in Mead's view, "a new kind of art form" — an innovation "as significant as the invention of drama or the novel".
News & Media
Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources
Similar Expressions
59 human-written examples
He presented his vision in three letter-size pages of equations which constitute, in the opinion of some judges, the most important document of the century; some regard it as the greatest intellectual effort of man.
News & Media
The proof masses are also used as inertial references for the drag-free control of the spacecraft which constitute in return a shield against external forces.
Science
For instance, U is used to model the switches of the hidden process X[25], which constitutes in some manner, a way to deal with nonstationary aspect of X discussed in the previous section.
The result is a spectrum of phenotypically diverse populations which constitute in excess of 1400 recorded breeds [2].
Science
The kidneys and the liver are the major organs involved in detoxification processes of endo- and xenomolecules, which constitute in return the primary function of these organs.
We could not reproduce these results with CCE at the dose of 50 mg/kg of body weight, a dose which is clearly effective on starch response and which constitutes, in our point of view, a more physiological dose regarding further applications in humans.
The most widely expressed and most common receptor subtype is a combination of two α type 1 subunits with two β type 2 and one γ type 2, which constitute in the region of 40% of receptors in the mammalian brain [ 1].
Science
The interrogations included the use of "enhanced interrogation techniques," such as waterboarding, which constituted torture in the judgment of the Red Cross and many other authorities.
News & Media
MVs were particularly high for awareness of positive symptoms (23%), awareness of negative symptoms (16%), and the index (13%), which constituted problems in terms of construct validity and reliability testing of the scale [ 54].
Science
In addition, the items about management, staffing and overall perception of patient safety which constituted four factors in the Dutch HSOPS, were structured in three factors in SCOPE.
Science
Expert writing Tips
Best practice
Avoid using the phrase "which constituted in". Opt for more grammatically correct alternatives like "which constituted" or "which formed part of".
Common error
The verb "constitute" does not typically take the preposition "in" after it. Using "in" creates an awkward and ungrammatical construction. Always use "constitute" followed directly by the object.
Source & Trust
82%
Authority and reliability
1.8/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested
Linguistic Context
The phrase "which constituted in" functions as a relative clause attempting to modify a noun. However, the inclusion of "in" after "constituted" is grammatically unsound. As Ludwig AI points out, this construction is not standard in English.
Frequent in
Science
50%
News & Media
50%
Formal & Business
0%
Less common in
Wiki
0%
Encyclopedias
0%
Reference
0%
Ludwig's WRAP-UP
In summary, the phrase "which constituted in" is generally considered grammatically incorrect in standard English. As Ludwig AI points out, the verb "constitute" does not typically take the preposition "in" after it. It is recommended to use alternative phrases such as "which constituted", "which comprised", or "which was composed of" to convey the intended meaning more effectively and accurately. While some examples exist, primarily in scientific and news media contexts, these instances are better replaced with more conventional grammatical structures.
More alternative expressions(10)
Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:
which formed part of
Replaces "constituted in" with a more common and grammatically sound expression indicating inclusion.
which was a component of
Emphasizes the role of being a part or element of something larger.
which comprised
A more concise way of saying "which was composed of", focusing on the elements included.
which made up
A simpler, more informal way to indicate the parts that compose something.
which consisted of
Highlights the elements that something is made of or includes.
which involved
Focuses on the elements or actions included within something.
which included
Indicates that something contains or encompasses certain elements.
which played a role in
Emphasizes the involvement or contribution of something to a larger process or entity.
which was instrumental in
Highlights the crucial or significant role of something.
which was defined by
Shifts the focus to the defining characteristics or attributes of something.
FAQs
Is "which constituted in" grammatically correct?
No, "which constituted in" is not grammatically correct in standard English. The verb "constitute" doesn't usually take the preposition "in" in this context. Use alternatives such as "which constituted" or "which comprised" instead.
What's a better way to phrase a sentence using "constituted"?
Instead of saying "which constituted in", try using phrases like "which was composed of", "which consisted of", or simply "which constituted" followed by the object.
Can I use a different preposition after "constituted"?
The verb "constitute" generally doesn't require a preposition after it when indicating what something is composed of. Using prepositions like "in", "of", or "by" after "constituted" is usually grammatically incorrect. It is better to use "which constituted" followed by the elements or parts.
What does "constituted" mean?
The word "constituted" means to compose or form something. When used in a sentence, it indicates what something is made up of or how it is structured. Therefore, "which constituted" means that the subject of the sentence formed or composed something else.
Editing plus AI, all in one place.
Stop switching between tools. Your AI writing partner for everything—polishing proposals, crafting emails, finding the right tone.
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Source & Trust
82%
Authority and reliability
1.8/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested