Ai Feedback
Exact(6)
In such instances, the problem with forced care cannot be simply violation of autonomy.
Thus, any action deemed wrong due to a violation of autonomy is derivatively wrong on instrumental grounds as well.
While the case study may not merit a violation of autonomy through disclosure, it does remind the ethicist that medicine cannot always concern itself solely with the individual patient and professional.
We are, I think, obligated to ask not just "who next?" but "why?" Why is this violation of autonomy and dignity as pervasive as it is pernicious?
In the former case, to minimize the effect of violation of autonomy, we should accept donation from a competent adult who agrees to donate rather than harvest tissue from a minor who cannot consent.
As Doyal recently argued, coercive measures can only be justified when there is assurance that a strategy of minimal violation of autonomy in place and non-threatening treatment options available [ 38].
Similar(54)
Results indicate that the evaluation of risk and mental illness, as well as perceived violations of autonomy and discrimination shaped participants' views on the justification of their compulsory admission and treatment.
A prediction from our findings is, for example, that – compared to violations of honesty or respect – medical professionals will be less likely to quickly identify violations of autonomy in specific practical clinical problems as a moral issue (due to the particularly low morality ratings of autonomy).
In particular, it is difficult to see how torturing (but not killing) the guilty terrorist and saving the lives of thousands could be morally worse than refraining from torturing him and allowing him to murder thousands torturing the terrorist is a temporary infringement of his autonomy, whereas his detonating of the nuclear device is a permanent violation of the autonomy of thousands.
You might argue that observing Constitution Day is not actually mandatory because the schools have a choice: if they believe that observing Constitution Day is a violation of their autonomy, they can refuse federal money.
Mandating that women be legally forced to undergo transvaginal ultrasound or any other medical procedure against their will and against their physician's judgment is an outrageous violation of patient autonomy and the confidential doctor-patient relationship.
Related(20)
violation of self
infringement of autonomy
violation of right
violation of liberty
violation of neutrality
violation of responsibility
violation of freedom
violation of separation
denial of autonomy
violation of government
invasion of autonomy
failure of autonomy
infringements of autonomy
breaches of autonomy
violation of nature
violation of democracy
violation of parking
violation of air
violation of privacy
violation of labor
Write better and faster with AI suggestions while staying true to your unique style.
Since I tried Ludwig back in 2017, I have been constantly using it in both editing and translation. Ever since, I suggest it to my translators at ProSciEditing.

Justyna Jupowicz-Kozak
CEO of Professional Science Editing for Scientists @ prosciediting.com