withstand critical evaluation

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "withstand critical evaluation" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used when discussing the ability of an idea, argument, or work to endure scrutiny or analysis from others. Example: "The research findings are robust and can withstand critical evaluation from experts in the field."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Encyclopedias

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

1 human-written examples

Any custom, homophobic or otherwise, that cannot withstand critical evaluation should simply be assigned to a dustbin of historic embarrassments.

The Guardian

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

59 human-written examples

We have to see if their results withstand critical scrutiny.

The New York Times - Science

His naïve explanation could not long withstand critical examination.

Encyclopedia Britannica

These are short films that withstand critical analysis.

Independent

They are already used in motor vehicles for components that have to withstand critical loads.

The Economist

The longer answer is that researchers are developing theories that, should they withstand critical scrutiny, may tie at least some of the erratic weather to global warming.

The New York Times - Science

Whether the new report will withstand critical scrutiny is uncertain; advocacy groups and most outside scientists had not learned of it on Tuesday.

The New York Times - Science

The question implicitly raised by Hume's powerful skeptical arguments is whether any epistemological authority at all can withstand critical scrutiny.

SEP

The lawyer goes on to argue that the ad campaign's "statements" are not based on science and would not withstand "critical analysis".

TechCrunch

Do these distinctions withstand critical scrutiny?

Bioethics

We argue that this prevailing assumption cannot withstand critical scrutiny.

BMC Medical Research Methodology

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using "withstand critical evaluation", ensure that the subject being evaluated is thoroughly supported by evidence and logical reasoning. This phrase implies a high degree of resilience and robustness.

Common error

Avoid using "withstand critical evaluation" if the subject has known weaknesses or limitations. Overstating its resilience can undermine credibility.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "withstand critical evaluation" functions as a verb phrase followed by a noun phrase, indicating the ability of something to endure thorough scrutiny. Ludwig's AI response confirms that the phrase is correct and usable in written English. It is often used in contexts where the robustness of an idea or argument is being assessed.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

30%

Science

30%

Encyclopedias

20%

Less common in

Formal & Business

10%

Academia

5%

Wiki

5%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

The phrase "withstand critical evaluation" signifies the capacity of an idea, argument, or object to endure rigorous analysis and scrutiny. Ludwig confirms that the phrase is grammatically sound and appropriate for use in written English. It is commonly found in contexts related to news, science, and encyclopedic discussions. While the phrase suggests resilience, it's essential to avoid overstating this quality if the subject has weaknesses. Alternatives include phrases like "hold up under scrutiny" and "stand up to analysis". Using "withstand critical evaluation" implies the subject has been thoroughly vetted and remains valid even after close inspection.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

hold up under scrutiny

This alternative focuses on the ability to maintain validity when closely examined.

stand up to analysis

This alternative emphasizes the ability to remain valid after a thorough analysis.

pass the test of critical review

This alternative highlights successfully completing a critical assessment.

survive rigorous assessment

This alternative concentrates on the ability to continue existing after a harsh assessment.

bear close inspection

This alternative highlights the capacity to undergo a detailed examination.

prove valid under examination

This alternative stresses the demonstration of validity through investigation.

endure detailed scrutiny

This alternative focuses on the ability to last through intense examination.

hold water under examination

This alternative uses an idiomatic expression to convey the ability to remain sound when investigated.

prove resilient when evaluated

This alternative accentuates the adaptability when undergoing assessment.

hold its own against critique

This alternative underscores the capacity to maintain its position even when criticized.

FAQs

How can I use "withstand critical evaluation" in a sentence?

You might say, "The scientist believed that her hypothesis could "withstand critical evaluation" from her peers".

What are some alternatives to "withstand critical evaluation"?

Consider using phrases like "hold up under scrutiny", "stand up to analysis", or "pass the test of critical review".

Is it better to say "withstand critical evaluation" or "withstand scrutiny"?

Both are valid, but "withstand critical evaluation" emphasizes a more formal and thorough assessment, while "withstand scrutiny" is more general. The choice depends on the specific context.

What does it mean for something to "withstand critical evaluation"?

It means that the idea, argument, or creation is robust and well-supported enough to endure rigorous examination and critique without being invalidated.