which has since been

USAGE SUMMARY

"which has since been" is correct and usable in written English.
It is used to refer to something that happened in the past and has continued until the present. For example: "He bought his first car when he was 18, which has since been replaced by a newer model."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Wiki

Formal & Business

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

59 human-written examples

It previously ran this disclaimer, which has since been removed.

Independent

The money, which has since been written off, went through.

The Guardian

A similar riot wrecked the Nauru camp last year, which has since been rebuilt.

The Economist

The lawn in front of the Reichstag, which has since been closed to tourists, is quiet.

The New York Times

The banner, which has since been taken down, was branded "inappropriate" and "disgusting".

Independent

Hackers rebutted those claims in their online post, which has since been withdrawn from the Web.

The New York Times

The drug in question, which has since been branded as Zalbin, has been abandoned.

The New York Times

Córtez still lives near that building, which has since been converted into a museum.

The Guardian - Travel

The recovered after receiving doses of an experimental drug which has since been depleted.

The Guardian

He arrested Mr. Gates on a disorderly conduct charge, which has since been dropped.

The New York Times

An earlier version used an inaccurate quote from a different article which has since been updated.

The Guardian - Tech

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Use "which has since been" to clearly indicate that a change has occurred from a previous state to the present.

Common error

Avoid using "which has since been" when the timeline of events is unclear or when the change is not directly relevant to the context. Instead, opt for a more direct and specific description of the change.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "which has since been" functions as a non-restrictive relative clause, providing additional, non-essential information about a noun phrase. As Ludwig AI points out, it indicates a state or condition that has changed from a previous one. The examples showcase its use in various contexts, adding detail about alterations or updates.

Expression frequency: Very common

Frequent in

News & Media

67%

Wiki

12%

Formal & Business

5%

Less common in

Science

10%

Encyclopedias

0%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "which has since been" is a versatile phrase used to provide additional information about a subject and highlight changes or updates that have occurred. As Ludwig AI confirms, it's grammatically sound and widely accepted in written English. Its neutral register makes it suitable for a variety of contexts, particularly in news and media, but also in Wiki and formal documents. Understanding the nuances of its usage, as well as common errors to avoid, can help writers enhance clarity and precision in their writing. The phrase functions as a non-restrictive relative clause, adding important context without changing the core meaning of the sentence.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

that has been subsequently

Emphasizes the sequential nature of the change.

which is now

Directly states the present condition contrasting to the past.

that was subsequently

Focuses on the sequence of events, highlighting that something happened after.

that subsequently became

Emphasizes the transformation into something else.

that was later

Indicates that something happened at a later time.

that was eventually

Highlights the final result after a period of time.

which was previously

Highlights a contrast between the previous state and the current state.

that had been

Implies a past state before the current one.

that is now

Focuses on the current state, contrasting it with the past.

that was at one time

Indicates a state that existed in the past but no longer exists.

FAQs

How to use "which has since been" in a sentence?

Use "which has since been" to add extra information about something that has changed over time. For example, "The original policy, "which has since been" updated, no longer applies."

What can I say instead of "which has since been"?

You can use alternatives like "that was later", "which was previously", or "that is now" depending on the context.

Is it correct to say "that has since been" instead of "which has since been"?

While "that has since been" is grammatically acceptable, "which has since been" is preferred when introducing a non-restrictive clause that provides additional, non-essential information.

What's the difference between "which has since been" and "which has now been"?

"Which has since been" indicates a change that occurred at some point in the past and continues to the present, while "which has now been" emphasizes the current state following a recent change.