this premise is invalid

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "this premise is invalid" is correct and usable in written English.
You can use it when discussing logical arguments or reasoning, indicating that a particular assumption or basis for an argument is flawed or incorrect. Example: "In the context of this debate, it is clear that this premise is invalid, as it does not hold up under scrutiny."

✓ Grammatically correct

Science

News & Media

Academia

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

1 human-written examples

This premise is invalid if patients refill their medication, particularly in the case of low out-of-pocket costs, but are reluctant regarding intake.

BMC Cancer

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

59 human-written examples

Our results demonstrate that this assumption is invalid in general.

Advanced Structural and Chemical Imaging

However, as shown in 67 68, this assumption is invalid.

Lingua Sinica

But in practice this assumption is invalid.

BMC Women's Health

Yet this premise is false.

The New York Times

But this premise is flawed.

The New York Times

For this premise is just bad economics.

The New York Times

This premise is simply untenable.

Cornell University

This premise is wrong.

TechCrunch

This premise is based on two principles.

Fibrogenesis and Tissue Repair

This premise is false (Jones, 2010).

WikiHow

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When critiquing an argument, clearly and directly state why "this premise is invalid" rather than vaguely dismissing it. Support your claim with evidence and logical reasoning.

Common error

Do not automatically assume a premise is invalid simply because you disagree with it. Analyze it objectively and identify genuine flaws in its logic or supporting evidence before declaring "this premise is invalid".

Linguistic Context

The phrase "this premise is invalid" functions as a critical assertion within a logical argument. It's used to directly challenge the validity of a foundational assumption or belief. Ludwig examples show it negates propositions in scientific papers, opinion pieces, and legal contexts. The AI confirms that the phrase is grammatically correct.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

Science

50%

News & Media

33%

Academia

17%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Wiki

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

The phrase "this premise is invalid" is a direct and critical assertion used to challenge the foundation of an argument. As Ludwig AI confirms, it is grammatically correct and most commonly found in science, news, and academic contexts. Its purpose is to disprove or undermine a claim by highlighting a flaw in its underlying assumption. While examples are relatively uncommon, the phrase's precise language lends itself to formal and scientific registers. Related phrases, like "this assumption is flawed", offer similar meanings with slight variations in emphasis. Using the phrase effectively requires clearly articulating why the premise is invalid with supporting evidence. Overall, the expression provides the writer with an effective tool to dissect arguments.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

This assumption is incorrect

Replaces "premise" with "assumption" and uses "incorrect" instead of "invalid".

This argument is unsound

Substitutes "premise" with "argument" and "invalid" with "unsound", focusing on the argument's logical validity.

There's a defect in this premise

Highlights the presence of a defect within the premise.

The basis for this is flawed

Replaces "premise" with "basis" and uses "flawed" instead of "invalid", highlighting the defect in the foundation.

This is based on a false assumption

Emphasizes the falsity of the underlying assumption, changing the structure slightly.

This is an untenable position

Declares the premise as indefensible or unsustainable.

This rests on shaky ground

Uses a metaphor to suggest the instability of the premise.

The foundation of this is weak

Focuses on the weakness of the foundation, using different vocabulary.

This is built on a fallacy

Identifies the premise as a logical fallacy.

The reasoning here is faulty

Shifts the focus to the reasoning process being defective.

FAQs

How can I use "this premise is invalid" in a sentence?

You can use "this premise is invalid" to argue against a statement. For example, "The argument fails because "this premise is invalid" since it relies on outdated data."

What's a good alternative to saying "this premise is invalid"?

Alternatives include "this assumption is flawed", "the basis for this is incorrect", or "this argument is unsound", depending on the specific nuance you want to convey.

When is it appropriate to state that "this premise is invalid"?

It's appropriate when you can demonstrate that the underlying assumption of an argument is factually incorrect, logically inconsistent, or based on insufficient evidence. Always provide a clear explanation for your claim.

Is it too strong to say "this premise is invalid"?

The strength of the statement depends on the context and your confidence in your assessment. If you're uncertain, you might soften it by saying "this premise appears questionable" or "this rests on shaky ground".