substantive advice

USAGE SUMMARY

"substantive advice" is correct and usable in written English.
You can use it to refer to advice that is meaningful and valuable. For example, "John gave me some great substantive advice that really helped me with my project."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Academia

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

6 human-written examples

"Throughout his writings," Smith concludes, "Strauss remained deeply skeptical of whether political theory had any substantive advice or direction to offer statesmen".

The New York Times - Books

Brown told Guardian Australia that Turnbull's decision to keep the group going represented an opportunity to get back to "core business" by providing the prime minister with "substantive advice" on Indigenous affairs.

The Guardian

While these five fundamentals have applicability to almost any negotiation you will encounter, Ambassador Koh also offered substantive advice for those negotiators facing far more complex negotiations, such as those involving various international interests.

Harvard University

"When the accusations were first made, there were Russians who said, 'You see, the Americans said they would come and be a big help and be selfless, and here they were just like everybody else, dipping in the pot,' " said Marshall Goldman, associate director of the Center for Russian Studies at Harvard, who has also challenged the wisdom of the substantive advice that the Shleifer team gave.

The New York Times

To give substantive advice, to be able to detach the 'ought' statement, we need to eliminate the subjectivity of the condition in the hypothetical; we need at least something that would make a coherent all-things-considered option.

SEP

FAO following its mandate and comparative advantages, would provide substantive advice and capacity building on specific technical fields and normative matters.

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

54 human-written examples

That business seems to have less to do with substantive fitness advice than showing off.

Vice

His substantive policy advice -- deregulation and far higher executive compensation -- makes him one of the principal German architects of the crisis.

HuffPost

"There was little appetite to question Lord Goldsmith about his advice and no substantive discussion of the legal issues was recorded," Chilcot finds.

The Guardian - Opinion

The Brazilian midfielder Alexandre Pato, who joined Chelsea on loan from an unhappy spell at Corinthians in January 2016, was the other player recorded as having no advice on the substantive terms of his contract.

The Guardian - Sport

An important result of the test phase was the report of the short-haul pilots that their advice was not substantive enough.

BMC Public Health

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using "substantive advice", ensure the context clearly indicates the advice is both important and directly relevant to the matter at hand. Avoid using it for trivial suggestions.

Common error

While "substantive advice" is grammatically correct, using it in casual conversations can sound overly formal or pretentious. Opt for simpler terms like "helpful tips" or "good ideas" in informal settings.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "substantive advice" functions as an adjective-noun combination. "Substantive" modifies "advice", indicating that the advice is meaningful, important, and not superficial. Ludwig examples highlight its use in contexts where significant guidance is provided.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

News & Media

40%

Academia

40%

Science

20%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Wiki

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "substantive advice" is a grammatically sound phrase used to describe meaningful and valuable guidance. Although it's not a very common phrase, according to Ludwig AI, it appears most frequently in news, academic, and science-related contexts. If a more informal tone is desired, alternatives like "helpful tips" or "good suggestions" may be more suitable. Remember to reserve "substantive advice" for situations where the guidance offered carries significant weight and relevance.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

meaningful guidance

Replaces "substantive" with a more common synonym, focusing on the significance of the advice.

valuable counsel

Substitutes both words, emphasizing the worth and formality of the advice.

significant input

Shifts the focus to the contribution made by the advice, rather than its inherent quality.

practical recommendations

Highlights the action-oriented nature of the advice.

insightful direction

Emphasizes the deep understanding and clarity provided by the advice.

constructive feedback

Focuses on the helpful and developmental aspect of the advice.

in-depth consultation

Highlights the thoroughness and expertise involved in providing the advice.

knowledgeable assistance

Emphasizes the expertise behind the advice.

considered opinion

Focuses on the thoughtful nature of the advice given.

major recommendation

Highlights the importance of the recommendation.

FAQs

How can I use "substantive advice" in a sentence?

You can use "substantive advice" to describe significant and valuable guidance. For example: "The professor provided "substantive advice" on my research paper."

What are some alternatives to "substantive advice"?

Alternatives include "meaningful guidance", "valuable counsel", or "significant input", depending on the specific nuance you want to convey.

Is "substantive advice" formal or informal?

"Substantive advice" leans towards the formal side. In more casual settings, phrases like "helpful tips" or "good suggestions" might be more appropriate.

What makes advice "substantive"?

Advice is considered "substantive" when it is meaningful, important, and directly relevant to the issue at hand. It goes beyond superficial suggestions and offers real value.