revision comment

USAGE SUMMARY

"revision comment" is a correct and usable part of a sentence in written English.
You can use it to refer to a comment made by a teacher or editor on how to adjust or revise a piece of writing. For example, "My professor gave me a revision comment about my essay that suggested I rethink my approach to the topic."

✓ Grammatically correct

Science

News & Media

Formal & Business

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

60 human-written examples

We are very grateful to the anonymous referee for revision comments and helpful suggestions.

Plosone

We thank Erica Tsai for detailed explanations on how to statistically compare IMa parameter estimates and Pieternella Luttikhuizen and one anonymous reviewer for providing extensive revisions, comments, and suggestions.

Plosone

Liou and Peng (2009) More revision oriented comments than non-revision-oriented comments after training.

International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education

Such results are similar to the results in in Liang (2008, 2010) in respect to the higher number of revision-oriented comments, but those comments leading to text revisions in Liang's studies were classified into different focus areas: content, meanings and errors.

International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education

PN was responsible for study implementation and protocol revision and commented on the draft.

BMC Infectious Diseases

Minor points for revision and comments: When a coding DNA reference sequence is used the following recommendations can be followed according to HGVS; the coding DNA reference sequence should be complete and preferably derived from the  RefSeq database   (format NM_033337.2).

F1000Research

According to Song and Usaha (2009), in the FFPR peer review, out of the total revision-oriented comments (n = 364), 292 comments were incorporated into subsequent text revisions.

International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education

On the other hand, in the asynchronous and synchronous CAPR peer review mode, out of the total revision-oriented comments (N = 300), 257 comments were integrated into learners' text revisions.

International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education

More interestingly, the same researchers found that learners made a higher number of global revision-oriented comments than the local revision-oriented comments.

International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education

Bradley (2014) More global revision-oriented comments (250/8 0) than local revision-oriented comments (64/20%).

International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education

Pham and Usaha (2015) After training, a higher number of global revision-oriented comments (552/60.2%) than local revision-oriented comments (365/39.8%).

International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When providing a "revision comment", be specific and actionable to ensure the recipient understands the suggested changes and can implement them effectively.

Common error

Avoid leaving generic "revision comments" such as "This needs improvement". Always provide specific details and examples to guide the writer towards a better outcome.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "revision comment" functions primarily as a noun phrase. It identifies a specific type of feedback, typically related to improving or altering a piece of written work. According to Ludwig, the phrase is a correct and usable part of a sentence in written English.

Expression frequency: Missing

Frequent in

Science

0%

News & Media

0%

Formal & Business

0%

Less common in

Science

0%

News & Media

0%

Formal & Business

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

The phrase "revision comment" is a grammatically correct noun phrase used to describe feedback aimed at improving a written piece. Despite its grammatical correctness, Ludwig indicates that there are limited real-world examples of this phrase in use, leading to its classification as 'Missing' in terms of frequency. However, Ludwig AI confirms its usability in written English. The phrase finds relevance across various contexts, including Science, News & Media, and Formal & Business settings, where detailed feedback is crucial. While the specific tone and language of the comment itself can vary, the phrase "revision comment" remains a useful term for discussing editorial and improvement processes.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

revision suggestion

A direct and simple alternative emphasizing the act of suggesting a change.

feedback on revisions

Focuses on the act of giving feedback related to changes made.

note for revision

Highlights that the note is specifically intended to be used for making revisions.

suggestion for improvement

Highlights the intent to enhance the quality of the work.

comment on draft

Focuses on providing feedback on a preliminary version of the document.

editorial note

Implies a formal comment typically provided by an editor.

recommendation for changes

Directly suggests specific changes to be implemented.

reviewer's remark

Specific to comments made during a formal review process.

constructive criticism

Emphasizes the helpfulness and positive intent of the comment.

input on modifications

Focuses on providing feedback regarding alterations or adjustments made.

FAQs

How can I effectively use "revision comment" in a sentence?

Use "revision comment" to refer to feedback given on a piece of writing that suggests changes. For example, "The editor's "revision comment" helped me improve the clarity of my essay."

What are some alternatives to saying "revision comment"?

You can use alternatives like "feedback on revisions", "suggestion for improvement", or "editorial note" depending on the context.

What distinguishes a "revision comment" from general feedback?

A "revision comment" is specifically aimed at guiding changes or improvements in a document or piece of writing. General feedback might be broader and not directly focused on alterations, whereas a revision comment pinpoints areas needing modification.

Is "revision comment" appropriate for formal writing?

Yes, "revision comment" is appropriate for formal writing, especially in academic or professional contexts when discussing feedback processes. However, the specific tone and language of the comment itself should also align with the formal context.