logically inconsistent

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "logically inconsistent" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used when discussing arguments, statements, or theories that contradict each other or do not follow logical reasoning. Example: "The theory presented in the paper is logically inconsistent, as it contradicts established scientific principles."

✓ Grammatically correct

Academia

News & Media

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

58 human-written examples

An understanding of the Asian perception towards death is also necessary for handling and interpreting logically inconsistent values in health preferences [ 17], because the logical order of health states (from worst to best) may be different in different cultures.

Health and Quality of Life Outcomes

We have problems with probabilities, and are logically inconsistent.

The Guardian - Books

Sadly for AT&T, that 'AND' is logically inconsistent with the preceding 'IF/THEN'IF/THEN

Harvard Business Review

This striking disparity is logically inconsistent and represents a naïve optimism on behalf of business leaders.

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Shortly after the verdict, Mr. Neary filed a motion seeking either the priest's acquittal or a new trial on grounds the jury's verdict was logically inconsistent.

The New York Times

At the same time, their opposition to May's deal is logically inconsistent with their own argument that May has underplayed the UK's hand.

The Guardian - Opinion

The growth of knowledge thus proceeds through the elimination of error i.e., through the refutation of hypotheses that are either logically inconsistent or entail empirically refuted consequences.

Britannica

AMA maintains that in light of these two factors it is logically inconsistent to retain joint and several liability of concurrent tortfeasors after Li.

Harvard University

Swearing allegiance to an Israel that is Jewish and democratic is logically inconsistent and an attempt to relegate Palestinian citizens of Israel to inferior status.

The New York Times

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

2 human-written examples

As for Seminole Tribe, we explain elsewhere, see infra, at 15—17, how that case was logically and practically inconsistent with Parden, even though it did not expressly overrule it.

Cornell University

That is, to argue that an opponent's view is inconsistent, logically or pragmatically, with other things he has said or to which he is committed.

SEP

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using "logically inconsistent", ensure that you clearly identify the specific elements or statements that are in contradiction. This helps to avoid ambiguity and strengthens your argument.

Common error

Avoid using "logically inconsistent" as a general term for 'disagreeable' or 'unfavorable'. The term specifically refers to contradictions in reasoning, not merely personal preferences.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "logically inconsistent" functions as an adjective phrase, modifying a noun to describe something that contains a contradiction or violates logical principles. As Ludwig AI confirms, it is used to point out flaws in reasoning or arguments.

Expression frequency: Very common

Frequent in

Science

38%

News & Media

31%

Academia

17%

Less common in

Encyclopedias

4%

Wiki

4%

Formal & Business

2%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "logically inconsistent" functions as an adjective phrase used to denote contradictions or violations of logical principles. As Ludwig AI indicates, it's grammatically correct and frequently used across various contexts. Primarily found in academic, scientific, and news media, it serves to critique flawed reasoning. To enhance clarity when using this phrase, precisely identify the contradictory elements. Alternatives include "self-contradictory" and "incoherent". Avoid using it as a generic term for disagreement. By understanding its proper use, writers can effectively employ "logically inconsistent" to strengthen their arguments and analysis.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

self-contradictory

Emphasizes that something contradicts itself within its own terms.

internally contradictory

Indicates a direct contradiction within a single statement or argument.

incoherent

Stresses the lack of clarity or logical connection in a statement or idea.

mutually exclusive

Highlights that two or more ideas cannot coexist or be true simultaneously.

irreconcilable

Indicates that two or more things cannot be brought into agreement or harmony.

paradoxical

Suggests a statement that appears self-contradictory but may contain a deeper truth.

incongruous

Implies a lack of harmony or compatibility between elements.

irrational

Suggests a lack of sound reasoning or logical thought.

at odds

Highlights the conflict or disagreement between different perspectives or arguments.

fallacious

Implies that the reasoning is flawed or based on incorrect information.

FAQs

How can I use "logically inconsistent" in a sentence?

You can use "logically inconsistent" to describe arguments, statements, or ideas that contain a contradiction or lack a coherent connection. For example: "His claims about reducing taxes while increasing public spending are "logically inconsistent"".

What are some alternatives to saying "logically inconsistent"?

Alternatives include "self-contradictory", "mutually exclusive", or "incoherent". The best choice depends on the specific context and the nature of the contradiction.

What does it mean for something to be "logically inconsistent"?

If something is "logically inconsistent", it means that its parts contradict each other, or it violates the basic principles of logic, making it impossible for all of its claims to be true simultaneously.

Is there a difference between something being "logically inconsistent" and just being wrong?

Yes. "Logically inconsistent" means that the different parts of an argument or statement contradict each other. Something that is simply wrong may be internally consistent but disagree with established facts or evidence.