has a comparable effect to

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "has a comparable effect to" is correct and usable in written English.
You can use it when discussing similarities in the impact or outcome of two different things or actions. Example: "The new policy has a comparable effect to the previous one, leading to similar improvements in employee satisfaction."

✓ Grammatically correct

Science

News & Media

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

2 human-written examples

Since there are only a few control points in each domain (e.g. five in D2 and six in D1), minimizing their length has a comparable effect to smoothing.

Bioinformatics

Moreover, antagonism of GM-CSF markedly reduces established disease in mouse models of RA and has a comparable effect to that of anti-TNF treatment [ 49].

Arthritis Research and Therapy

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

58 human-written examples

Dr Diacon and his colleagues found that a combination of one experimental drug, one drug approved for other infectious diseases and one existing TB drug had a comparable effect to standard TB treatment.Importantly, the novel agents mean that the combination may fight some TB strains resistant to other drugs—and do so quite quickly.

The Economist

Both CM200 and CM400 had a comparable effect to CQ25, while CM600 appeared to have a better effect, although the result was not statistically significant (Table  2).

BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine

Although neither Fnip1 nor Fnip2 single knockdown had a strong impact, knockdown of both had a comparable effect to loss of Flcn.

Cell

Depleting α-tubulin, while having a comparable effect to γ-tubulin removal on germline structure, did not disrupt NOCA-1 targeting.

eLife

Although family size (i.e., having a child or children) did seem to have a significant effect on whether individuals shared more similar skin communities, having a child in our study cohort also did not have a comparable effect to age or dog ownership on community similarity or diversity.

eLife

CAVEATS Whether one's attitude toward life has a comparable effect on younger people was not studied.

The Washington Post

Listening to the great Lebanese vocalist Sister Marie Keyrouz intone Middle Eastern Christian chant or Tina Turner sing a Buddhist chant has a comparable effect.

The New York Times - Arts

Here we asked, whether an extension of physiological mental preparation has a comparable effect on MI and ME.

Cortex

Thus, we excluded a gain-of-function by a simple charge effect as a mechanism, as an acidic residue (glutamate) had a comparable effect as the substitution to a basic residue (lysine and arginine).

EMBO Molecular Medicine

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using "has a comparable effect to", ensure that both subjects of comparison are clearly defined and understood by your audience to avoid ambiguity.

Common error

Avoid using "has a comparable effect to" when the items being compared are not logically comparable or when the scale of effect is vastly different. For example, do not say "Eating an apple has a comparable effect to running a marathon" because the effects are not on the same scale.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "has a comparable effect to" functions as a predicate in a sentence, indicating that one thing produces results or consequences similar to another. As noted by Ludwig, this phrase is usable in written English. It is used to establish a comparison between two different entities regarding their influence or outcome.

Expression frequency: Common

Frequent in

Science

60%

News & Media

30%

Academia

10%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Wiki

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

The phrase "has a comparable effect to" is a grammatically correct and commonly used expression to indicate that two different things have similar impacts or outcomes. Ludwig's analysis of numerous examples confirms its wide applicability across different contexts, especially in science, news, and academic writing. When using this phrase, it's important to compare logically comparable items to maintain clarity and avoid misinterpretations. While alternatives like "has a similar impact as" or "is equally effective as" exist, "has a comparable effect to" remains a precise and useful choice for expressing similarity in effect.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

has a similar impact as

Focuses on the 'impact' rather than the 'effect', implying a strong influence or result.

has a parallel influence on

Highlights the 'influence' and suggests a side-by-side or corresponding action.

produces an equivalent outcome to

Emphasizes the 'outcome' or result, suggesting the effects are quantitatively equal.

yields a commensurate result with

Implies the result is proportional or corresponding in measure or degree.

is equally effective as

Focuses specifically on 'effectiveness', indicating comparable levels of success.

shows a like effect to

Emphasizes the 'likeness' or similarity in the manifestation of the effect.

exhibits a related consequence to

Highlights that the consequence is connected or associated.

is analogous in its effect to

Implies a parallel or resemblance in the way the effect operates.

functions in a comparable way to

Focuses on the 'function' or process, indicating similar operational behavior.

generates a corresponding reaction to

Highlights that the reaction is in response and connected.

FAQs

How can I use "has a comparable effect to" in a sentence?

Use "has a comparable effect to" to compare the impact of two different actions or things. For example, "The new drug "has a comparable effect to" the older one in reducing symptoms."

What are some alternatives to "has a comparable effect to"?

You can use alternatives like "has a similar impact as", "is equally effective as", or "produces an equivalent outcome to" depending on the context.

Which is correct: "has a comparable effect to" or "has a similar effect as"?

Both ""has a comparable effect to"" and "has a similar effect as" are generally acceptable, but "has a comparable effect to" is often considered more grammatically precise. Using "as" after "similar" can sometimes be seen as redundant.

What's the difference between "has a comparable effect to" and "has the same effect as"?

"Has a comparable effect to" implies a similarity in impact, while "has the same effect as" suggests an identical outcome. The first indicates that the effects are similar but not necessarily identical, while the second states that the results are the same.