Used and loved by millions
Since I tried Ludwig back in 2017, I have been constantly using it in both editing and translation. Ever since, I suggest it to my translators at ProSciEditing.

Justyna Jupowicz-Kozak
CEO of Professional Science Editing for Scientists @ prosciediting.com
had run separately
Grammar usage guide and real-world examplesUSAGE SUMMARY
The phrase "had run separately" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used to describe an action that occurred in the past where two or more subjects operated independently from each other. Example: "The two teams had run separately during the marathon, each following their own strategy."
✓ Grammatically correct
News & Media
Science
Alternative expressions(1)
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Human-verified examples from authoritative sources
Exact Expressions
1 human-written examples
But its election tally of 31 seats, the largest bloc in Israel's 120-seat parliament, was fewer than the sum of the two parties when they had run separately.
News & Media
Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources
Similar Expressions
56 human-written examples
One June complaint in the past, whether the two festivals have run separately, simultaneously or consecutively, has been that wilder and freer jazz was overshadowed by the mainstream monolith known as the JVC Jazz Festival.
News & Media
Inside Corbyn's team, key advisers were scrambling to understand how the row had run out of control on Tuesday, with some in the leaders' office – which is run separately to the campaign – complaining of too much freelancing.
News & Media
The heads of underwriting and sales will oversee fixed-income and equities functions; previously, the debt and equities functions had been run separately.
News & Media
Michael C. Bellas, the chairman and chief executive of Beverage Marketing, said of the businesses: "They've been run separately; from what I can gather they're doing just fine.
News & Media
In the case of paired end DNA measurements, BLAST has been run separately on both end.
Science
David Riedel, an analyst for Salomon Smith Barney, said the Frances have run Nascar and I.S.C. separately to avoid a conflict of interest.
News & Media
Now called the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the agency was created in March 1977 to coordinate the two programs, which since they were created in 1965 had essentially been run separately.
News & Media
The hybridisation products of each FLR had to be run separately, otherwise the antisense strand of one FLR would hybridise with the labelled strand of another FLR and produce a heteroduplex peak that cannot be differentiated from real alleles.
Science
Intra-cluster dependence within herd was adjusted for using the procedure described for Model 1. Due to the non-proportional hazard in different parities, the model had to be run separately for parity 1, 2 and > 2, respectively.
Intra-cluster dependence within herd was adjusted for using the procedure described for Model 1. Due to non-proportional hazard in different parities in culling hazard and different association to COD, the model had to be run separately for parity 1, 2 and > 2, respectively.
Expert writing Tips
Best practice
When using "had run separately", ensure that the context clearly indicates the entities or processes that were operating independently, enhancing clarity and avoiding ambiguity.
Common error
Avoid using "had run separately" when the entities or processes, although distinct, influenced each other. Use it only when independence is a key characteristic.
Source & Trust
80%
Authority and reliability
4.1/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested
Linguistic Context
The phrase "had run separately" functions as a verb phrase indicating a past action where two or more entities operated independently. Ludwig examples show it describing distinct operations or processes.
Frequent in
News & Media
40%
Science
35%
Formal & Business
10%
Less common in
Wiki
8%
Encyclopedias
4%
Academia
3%
Ludwig's WRAP-UP
The phrase "had run separately" describes a completed action in the past where entities or processes operated independently. According to Ludwig, the phrase is grammatically correct and appears frequently in news articles, scientific publications, and other sources. While alternatives like "operated independently" or "functioned apart" exist, the key is to ensure that the context emphasizes the distinct nature of the actions. When using "had run separately", clarity is crucial to avoid ambiguity. Always use "run", which is the past participle of the verb "run", and confirm that the entities in question did not influence each other.
More alternative expressions(10)
Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:
operated independently
This alternative replaces the verb "run" with "operated", emphasizing the independent action.
functioned apart
This alternative uses "functioned" to convey how distinct entities worked in isolation.
were conducted independently
This phrase specifies that actions were conducted without coordination.
were executed separately
This alternative focuses on the separate execution of tasks or processes.
were managed distinctly
This implies that different entities or tasks were under separate management.
were administered independently
This alternative is suitable when discussing procedures or systems being managed autonomously.
were handled individually
Highlights individual handling, emphasizing a lack of combined effort.
proceeded on their own
This alternative uses a more informal tone, suggesting autonomy in progression.
worked in isolation
This phrase underscores the lack of interaction between entities.
were treated as distinct entities
This alternative is useful when highlighting the separate treatment of different items or groups.
FAQs
How can I use "had run separately" in a sentence?
You can use "had run separately" to indicate that two or more entities or processes operated independently in the past. For example: "The two departments "had run separately" for years before the merger."
What are some alternatives to "had run separately"?
Alternatives include "operated independently", "functioned apart", or "were conducted independently", depending on the specific context.
Is it correct to say "had ran separately" instead of "had run separately"?
No, the correct form is "had run separately". "Run" is the past participle of the verb "run", which is required after the auxiliary verb "had".
What's the difference between "had run separately" and "were running separately"?
"Had run separately" indicates a completed action in the past, while "were running separately" describes a continuous action in the past. The choice depends on whether you're emphasizing the completion or duration of the separate operation.
Editing plus AI, all in one place.
Stop switching between tools. Your AI writing partner for everything—polishing proposals, crafting emails, finding the right tone.
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Source & Trust
80%
Authority and reliability
4.1/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested