had however become

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "had however become" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used to indicate a change or transformation that occurred in the past, often with a contrast implied by "however." Example: "The project had however become more complex than initially anticipated, requiring additional resources."

✓ Grammatically correct

Encyclopedia

News & Media

Science

Wiki

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

7 human-written examples

He had, however, become involved in a number of quarrels, often with his friends, resulting from the forcible expression of his views in the journals.

Encyclopedia Britannica

A concerted Allied attack, by the British and US air force on working-class districts of German and Japanese cities had, however, become more or less official policy by 1943.

The Guardian - Arts

He had, however, become critical of the development of Marxist thought and provoked the disapproval of the ruling Communist Party officials; the journal Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie, which he edited from 1953, was suppressed, he was forbidden to publish, and in 1957 his works were condemned.

Encyclopedia Britannica

It had, however, become clear to positivists who were actually engaged in the practice of science that the structure of a science is what sustains prediction, not the meaning of the theoretical terms of the science.

SEP

Bellette had, however, become an "onlooker" to the local art scene.

Wikipedia

The halyards that held up his pennant had however become tangled in the rigging, giving the appearance that the ship was still in French hands: this later led it to be attacked repeatedly by other British ships as they came up during the night.

Wikipedia

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

52 human-written examples

It has, however, become a problem for his children.

The Guardian

The canal system has, however, become popular for pleasure boating.

Encyclopedia Britannica

The civil service has, however, become increasingly centralised since Osborne first became chancellor in 2010.

The Guardian

Carpe diem has, however, become better known by a less literal translation: "seize the day".

Encyclopedia Britannica

It has, however, become a victim of its own success: queues form for a picture on the "Diana seat".

The Guardian - Travel

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using "had however become", ensure that the sentence clearly establishes a contrast or unexpected turn of events. This phrase works best when highlighting a transformation that occurred despite an opposing factor.

Common error

Avoid placing "however" too far from the words it modifies. Ensure that "however" immediately follows "had" to maintain clarity and avoid ambiguity.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "had however become" functions as a connector in sentences, indicating a transformation or state change that occurred despite a contrasting or unexpected element. It uses the past perfect tense to show a sequence of events, where one event preceded another in the past. Ludwig AI confirms the usability of this phrase.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

29%

Science

24%

Encyclopedias

21%

Less common in

Wiki

15%

Formal & Business

6%

Social Media

5%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

The phrase "had however become" is a grammatically sound construction used to express a past transformation in the face of a contrast. As confirmed by Ludwig AI, it is correctly used in a variety of writing contexts. While not as common as simpler alternatives, it offers a nuanced way to indicate that something changed unexpectedly or despite opposing factors. It appears most frequently in news articles, scientific publications, and encyclopedias, reflecting a neutral to formal register. When using this phrase, clarity is key: ensure that the contrast introduced by "however" is evident and logically connected to the surrounding information.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

had nonetheless transformed

Replaces "however become" with "nonetheless transformed", emphasizing the transformation despite an obstacle.

had still evolved into

Substitutes "however become" with "still evolved into", highlighting the gradual development despite a potential hindrance.

had unexpectedly turned into

Replaces "however become" with "unexpectedly turned into", stressing the surprise aspect of the transformation.

had in spite of that grown into

Replaces "however become" with "in spite of that grown into", emphasizing growth despite an impediment.

had regardless developed into

Substitutes "however become" with "regardless developed into", underlining the continuous development regardless of circumstances.

had yet materialized as

Replaces "however become" with "yet materialized as", indicating a result that came into being over time despite an existing situation.

had contrary to expectation emerged as

Replaces "however become" with "contrary to expectation emerged as", stressing the unexpected nature of the outcome.

had even so transitioned to

Substitutes "however become" with "even so transitioned to", highlighting the transition despite any existing challenges.

had withal changed to

Replaces "however become" with "withal changed to", emphasizing a change happening in addition to other circumstances.

had notwithstanding progressed to

Substitutes "however become" with "notwithstanding progressed to", stressing progression in spite of possible obstructions.

FAQs

How can I use "had however become" in a sentence?

Use "had however become" to indicate a transformation that occurred despite a contrasting factor or expectation. For example, "The initial plan was simple; it "had however become" quite complex."

What are some alternatives to "had however become"?

You can use alternatives such as "had nonetheless transformed", "had still evolved into", or "had unexpectedly turned into" to convey a similar meaning with slightly different emphasis.

Is it grammatically correct to say "had however become"?

Yes, "had however become" is grammatically correct. It uses the past perfect tense with "however" as an adverbial interrupter to show contrast. The sentence "The program "however had itself become" starved — of money" shows an alternative placement for "however" but is grammatically correct as well.

What's the difference between "had however become" and "has however become"?

"Had however become" indicates a transformation completed in the past relative to another past event, while "has however become" indicates a transformation completed in the past relative to the present. For example, "By the time we arrived, the situation "had however become" unmanageable," versus "The situation "has however become" challenging recently."