had been collaborated

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "had been collaborated" is not correct in English.
The correct form would typically be "had collaborated" or "had been collaborating," depending on the intended meaning. Example: "The team had collaborated on the project for several months before the deadline."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

Science

News & Media

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

1 human-written examples

The involved endoscopic centers had been collaborated for clinical research for a long time, and majority of the endoscopic centers in this study were also involved in other 2 Chinese national studies [ 7, 8], therefore the agreement among these assessors was generally good.

BMC Gastroenterology

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

59 human-written examples

The two were longtime research partners and had been collaborating on a study.

The New York Times - Health

Gang had been collaborating with Corwon to test some of her design ideas.

The New Yorker

Reporters, already mired in the phone-hacking scandal, had been collaborating with convicted prisoners.

The Guardian

In Baltimore, the Walters Art Museum had been collaborating with Johns Hopkins scientists on shows about creativity and the brain.

The New Yorker

Evans had been collaborating with a graceful, sophisticated and classically textured band led by Claude Thornhill, as were saxophonists Gerry Mulligan and Lee Konitz.

The Guardian - Music

In March 2018 the Observer and The New York Times simultaneously published articles on which they had been collaborating.

The Guardian - Opinion

Microsoft had been collaborating with Globo Cabo on the development of a broadband platform in Brazil.

Forbes

Cisco and Nicira had been collaborating through OpenStack on the Quantum Project.

TechCrunch

Both companies, which came out of Y Combinator, had been collaborating informally for a long time.

TechCrunch

In 2003 Novartis had been collaborating with Regeneron Pharmaceuticals to test Regeneron's interleukin-1 blocker in rheumatoid arthritis.

Forbes

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When describing collaborative efforts, use the correct grammatical form "had collaborated" or "had been collaborating" instead of "had been collaborated".

Common error

Avoid using "had been collaborated" because it incorrectly applies passive voice to a verb that describes an active, joint effort. Use active constructions like "had collaborated" or "had been collaborating" to clearly convey who was working together.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "had been collaborated" functions as a past perfect passive construction, although it is grammatically incorrect. Ludwig AI indicates that the correct forms are "had collaborated" or "had been collaborating."

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

Science

33%

News & Media

33%

Formal & Business

0%

Less common in

Academia

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Wiki

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "had been collaborated" is grammatically incorrect. The correct forms are "had collaborated" or "had been collaborating", depending on the intended meaning. As pointed out by Ludwig AI, it's crucial to use these grammatically correct alternatives to clearly express collaborative efforts in the past. While some sources might use the incorrect phrase, adhering to proper grammar enhances clarity and credibility, especially in formal or scientific writing. Using alternatives like "had worked together" can further clarify the nature of the collaboration.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

had collaborated

Corrects the grammatical error by removing "been".

had been working together

Emphasizes the joint effort or teamwork aspect.

had partnered

Focuses on the formal alliance between parties.

had cooperated

Highlights the willingness to work jointly.

had joined forces

Suggests a combined effort toward a common goal.

had united

Indicates merging efforts to create something.

had combined their efforts

Specifies a merging of separate contributions.

had acted jointly

Refers to a shared action or activity.

had allied

Suggests a formal agreement to collaborate.

had participated together

Highlights the mutual participation.

FAQs

Is "had been collaborated" grammatically correct?

No, "had been collaborated" is not grammatically correct. The correct forms are "had collaborated" or "had been collaborating".

What's the difference between "had collaborated" and "had been collaborating"?

"Had collaborated" indicates a completed action in the past, while "had been collaborating" suggests a collaborative effort that occurred over a period of time in the past.

What can I say instead of "had been collaborated"?

You can use alternatives like "had worked together", "had partnered", or "had cooperated" depending on the context.

How can I use "had collaborated" correctly in a sentence?

Use "had collaborated" in sentences like: "The researchers had collaborated on several projects before publishing their findings."