for fruitful comments

USAGE SUMMARY

"for fruitful comments" is a correct and usable phrase in written English.
You could use it in any written context to refer to comments or remarks that are insightful, helpful, or productive. For example, "We would like to thank everyone who contributed to our discussion today, especially those who made fruitful comments."

✓ Grammatically correct

Science

Science & Research

Academia

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

12 human-written examples

We thank J.A. Daròs, M.A. Fares and G. Rodrigo for fruitful comments and suggestions and O. Voinnet and C. Llave for sharing with us the TCV and TRV transcriptomic data, respectively.

Nature

We would like to thank Dr. G. Lecellier for statistical advice and Dr. J. Guezennec for fruitful comments on the manuscript.

AMB Express

We thank the Academic Editor and an anonymous reviewer for fruitful comments and suggestions on an earlier version of this manuscript.

Plosone

Special thanks to Prof. Dr. Julia Weiss for fruitful comments and suggestions.

BMC Infectious Diseases

We thank Oriol Canela Xandri and Pieter Rein ten Wolde for fruitful comments.

BMC Systems Biology

We thank all of our group members for fruitful comments and discussions.

BMC Systems Biology

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

48 human-written examples

We are also grateful to R. Harris for his fruitful comments on an early version of the manuscript.

Earth, Planets and Space

The authors also wish to thank Dmitri Rouwet and an anonymous reviewer for their fruitful comments on an earlier version of the manuscript.

Earth, Planets and Space

We would like to thank Anne Ingeborg Myhr, Georgina Catacora-Vargas and Anders Braarud Hanssen for their fruitful comments on earlier versions of this manuscript.

Environmental Sciences Europe

The authors also thank Boumédiène Derras for his help and advice about the artificial neural network approach and particularly the reviewers for their fruitful comments to improve this work.

Earth, Planets and Space

We are grateful to Richard Ivry and Bruno Averbeck for their fruitful comments on the manuscript.

Plosone

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When acknowledging contributions, be specific about the impact of the "fruitful comments". For example, "We thank the reviewers for their fruitful comments, which significantly improved the clarity of the manuscript."

Common error

Avoid using "for fruitful comments" in casual communication. Opt for simpler expressions like "thanks for the helpful feedback" in less formal settings.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "for fruitful comments" functions as a prepositional phrase expressing gratitude or acknowledgement. Ludwig's examples show its use in thanking individuals or reviewers for providing helpful and productive feedback, often in academic or scientific publications.

Expression frequency: Common

Frequent in

Science

40%

Science & Research

30%

Academia

20%

Less common in

News & Media

3%

Formal & Business

3%

Encyclopedias

1%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "for fruitful comments" is a grammatically correct and usable phrase employed to express gratitude for helpful and productive feedback, as indicated by Ludwig. Its primary use is in formal academic, scientific, and professional contexts. While the phrase is appropriate for expressing sincere appreciation, using it in informal conversation could sound unnatural. More casual phrases exist for those situations. Related phrases include "for valuable input" and "for insightful feedback". The phrase is commonly found in scientific publications, as demonstrated by the high frequency of authoritative sources like Nature and PlosOne. Therefore, while grammatically sound and useful, context is extremely important.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

for insightful feedback

Replaces "fruitful comments" with a more direct expression of the value of the feedback.

for valuable input

Substitutes "comments" with "input", suggesting contributions beyond just remarks.

for constructive criticism

Emphasizes the helpful and developmental nature of the comments.

for their helpful suggestions

Focuses on the suggestions provided, rather than general comments.

for their insightful observations

Highlights the perceptive quality of the comments.

for their productive feedback

Highlights the benefit of the comments in terms of productivity.

for their useful insights

Focuses on the beneficial insights gained from the comments.

for providing valuable feedback

This is an alternative in which the verb providing is added.

for sharing their expertise

Highlights the expertise that informed the comments.

for their critical analysis

Emphasizes the analytical depth and importance of the comments.

FAQs

How can I use "for fruitful comments" in a sentence?

You can use "for fruitful comments" to express gratitude for helpful feedback, especially in academic or scientific writing. For example, "We thank the reviewers "for fruitful comments" on the earlier draft of this manuscript."

What are some alternatives to saying "for fruitful comments"?

Depending on the context, you can use alternatives like "for valuable input", "for insightful feedback", or "for constructive criticism".

Is "fruitful comments" grammatically correct?

Yes, "fruitful comments" is grammatically correct. "Fruitful" is an adjective that appropriately modifies the noun "comments", indicating that the comments were productive or helpful.

When is it appropriate to use "for fruitful comments"?

"For fruitful comments" is most appropriate in formal contexts such as academic papers, research reports, or professional communications where you want to express gratitude for feedback that has significantly contributed to the improvement of your work.