comprising as

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "comprising as" is not correct and does not convey a clear meaning in written English.
It is not a standard expression and may confuse readers due to its unusual combination of words. Example: "The committee is comprising as a group of experts in various fields."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

News & Media

Science

Academia

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

19 human-written examples

Millions of smartphones using AOSP are sold in China every quarter, comprising as many as a third of all "Android" phones sold in the world.

The Guardian - Tech

The Peruvian anchoveta is by far the largest single species catch by tonnage in the world, some years comprising as much as 10% of all fish caught.

The Guardian - Lifestyle

We concurrently map relative levels of multiple histone modifications across multiple samples, each comprising as few as a thousand cells.

Molecular Cell

Mr. Slocombe declined to comment on how the Kurdish militia forces, now comprising as many as 70,000 pesh merga fighters, would be treated as the new army is created.

The New York Times

If emissions of greenhouse gases remain high, as many as 143 million "internal migrants" might move within their own countries, comprising as much as 3.5percentt of the total population of the studied regions by 2050, according to the report.

Columbia University

The control system is usually simple to learn, comprising as little as two buttons.

Wikipedia

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

41 human-written examples

In Scandinavia, where they are usually sold peeled and cooked, a pound may comprise as many as 300 shrimp.

The New York Times - Food

The sector as a whole comprises as many as 42,500 organisations, ranging from self-employed therapists to hospital groups such as Spire.

The Guardian

The Indonesian group comprised as many as 50 people, reports said, including Defense Minister Purnomo Yusgiantoro.

The New York Times

At the time, it was thought the genome might be comprised as many as 140,000 genes and it could take 15 years to sequence them all.

The Guardian

As now envisioned, the technology campus is to comprise as many as 22 buildings with laboratories, offices and hotels as well as services like a day care center and health club.

The New York Times

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Avoid using "comprising as" in formal writing. Opt for clearer and more grammatically accepted alternatives like "consisting of" or "including" to ensure clarity and precision.

Common error

A common mistake is to use "comprising as" when intending to describe the composition of something. This phrase is not grammatically standard. Instead, use more appropriate phrases such as "consisting of" or "including" to avoid grammatical errors and improve clarity.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "comprising as" functions as an attempt to describe the composition of something, but it is grammatically non-standard. Ludwig indicates that this is not a correct usage. Better alternatives exist to convey this meaning.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

30%

Science

40%

Academia

30%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Wiki

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, while the phrase "comprising as" appears in various sources, it is generally considered grammatically incorrect and non-standard English. Ludwig flags this phrase as not correct. Better alternatives, such as "consisting of", "including", and "composed of", offer clearer and more precise ways to describe the composition of something. Given the grammatical issues, it's best to avoid "comprising as" in formal and professional writing to ensure clarity and credibility. When aiming to specify the elements or components that constitute a whole, opt for grammatically sound alternatives to effectively communicate your intended meaning.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

consisting of

This alternative clearly and directly indicates the elements that make up something.

including

This alternative emphasizes the inclusion of specific items within a larger group.

composed of

Similar to 'consisting of', this highlights the components that form a whole.

made up of

This phrase describes the constitution of something from its constituent parts.

containing

This focuses on the presence of certain elements within something.

encompassing

This implies a broader scope of inclusion, covering a wide range of elements.

incorporating

This suggests that elements are integrated into a larger structure or system.

integrating

This alternative focuses on the process of elements coming together to form a cohesive whole.

characterized by

This highlights the defining attributes or features of something.

featuring

This emphasizes the presence of notable or prominent elements.

FAQs

What are some alternatives to the phrase "comprising as"?

Better alternatives to "comprising as" include "consisting of", "including", or "composed of". These options are grammatically correct and more widely accepted.

Is "comprising as" grammatically correct?

No, "comprising as" is not considered grammatically correct in standard English. It's advisable to use alternative phrases like "consisting of" or "including".

How can I use "consisting of" instead of "comprising as"?

Instead of saying "The team comprising as experts", say "The team "consisting of" experts". This provides a grammatically sound sentence.

What's wrong with using "comprising as"?

The phrase "comprising as" is not a standard English construction and may confuse readers. Using more conventional phrases like "consisting of" or "including" enhances clarity and credibility.