comparable group with

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "comparable group with" is not entirely correct in English; it would be better phrased as "comparable group to" or "comparable group of." You can use it when discussing groups that can be compared in terms of certain characteristics or metrics.
Example: "In our study, we analyzed the results from the treatment group and compared them to a comparable group with similar demographics."

Science

News & Media

Academia

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

4 human-written examples

Some of the figures from Constantino et al. (23) are quite concerning with prevalence rates of ischemic heart disease reaching as high as 13% at an age of 40 years compared with only 3% in the comparable group with type 1 diabetes whose mean age was 39 years.

Diabetes Care

In a study by researchers at Johns Hopkins, published in July in Circulation, healthy middle-aged people with high levels of C-reactive protein experienced less reduction in serum cholesterol and a greater rise in triglycerides when they followed a cholesterol-lowering diet than did a comparable group with low levels of CRP.

The New York Times - Health

Our results using TIP in a comparable group, with much shorter follow-up, again appeared inferior.

British Journal of Cancer

Relative survival is defined as the observed (all-cause) survival, S t), among the cancer patients divided by the expected survival, S ∗(t), in a comparable group (with respect to age, sex, calendar year and possibly other covariates) in the general population.

BMC Medical Research Methodology

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

56 human-written examples

We conclude that whilst our approach succeeded in applying the idea of comparable groups with different exposures to an observational, international comparison, it also brought associated questions about external validity and the extent to which a sample of matched areas captures a 'national' context.

Social Science & Medicine

In addition, the receiver operator characteristic analysis of each protein peak was performed for the comparable groups, with the area under the curve value calculated for each peak.

British Journal of Cancer

Baseline characteristics of study subjects will be contrasted to ascertain that randomization has in fact produced comparable groups with respect to all variables that effect the composition of breast milk including gestational age at delivery and duration since delivery.

BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth

Baseline characteristics of study subjects will be contrasted to ascertain that randomization has in fact produced comparable groups with respect to all variables that effect pain response and physiologic stability.

BMC Pediatrics

METHOD: Using propensity score matching, we assessed outcomes at follow-up for Medicare beneficiaries receiving TKA and a comparable group of beneficiaries with the same osteoarthritis diagnoses (controls).

Duke University

A second comparable group of 35 women, with gestational ages from 9 to 23 weeks, received a silastic device with a concentration of 1.0% of the prostaglandin.

Duke University

They gave 4-year-olds and 6-year-olds five days of training with these games and compared them to comparable groups of children with no training.

HuffPost

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When describing study groups, consider using "similar group to" or "equivalent group of" for improved clarity and grammatical precision.

Common error

Avoid using "with" after "comparable group"; instead, opt for "to" or "of" to align with standard English usage.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "comparable group with" functions primarily as an adjective phrase modifying the noun "group". It identifies a specific group that shares characteristics allowing for comparison with another group, as shown in the examples from Ludwig.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

Science

75%

News & Media

12%

Academia

12%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Wiki

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

The phrase "comparable group with" is used to identify a group suitable for comparison, predominantly within scientific and academic contexts. While understandable, Ludwig AI suggests that "similar group to" or "equivalent group of" are more grammatically sound alternatives. The phrase, although relatively rare, serves to specify a group sharing characteristics that allow for a meaningful comparison. When writing, consider opting for the suggested alternatives to ensure greater clarity and adherence to standard English usage.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

similar group to

Replaces "comparable" with "similar" and "with" with "to", offering a slightly different phrasing.

equivalent group of

Substitutes "comparable" with "equivalent" and rephrases the prepositional structure.

matching group with

Emphasizes the matching aspect of the comparison, keeping "with".

analogous group to

Uses "analogous" to indicate a similar relationship, changes the preposition.

corresponding group to

Indicates a direct correspondence between the groups, changing the preposition.

related group to

A more general term suggesting a relationship without specifying the nature of the comparison and changing the preposition

a group for comparison with

Focuses on the purpose of comparison; changes the phrase structure.

a parallel group to

Uses "parallel" to imply similar characteristics, changes the preposition.

a control group similar to

Specifies a control group, adding context and a different structure.

a cohort comparable to

Replaces "group" with "cohort" offering a more formal tone; changes the preposition.

FAQs

What's a more grammatically sound alternative to "comparable group with"?

You can use alternatives like "similar group to" or "equivalent group of" for better grammatical precision.

How can I use "comparable group with" in a sentence?

While "comparable group with" is understandable, it's better to say, "We compared the results with a similar group to ensure accuracy."

Is "comparable group with" formally correct?

While not incorrect, "comparable group with" is less formal. "Comparable group to" or "Comparable group of" are better choices for formal writing.

What is the difference between "comparable group with" and "comparable group to"?

"Comparable group to" is more grammatically correct and widely accepted than "comparable group with". The former indicates a direct comparison, while the latter is less common.