comment on the retraction

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "comment on the retraction" is correct and usable in written English.
You can use it when asking someone to provide their thoughts or feedback regarding a retraction, such as in an academic or professional context. Example: "I would like you to comment on the retraction issued by the journal regarding the previously published study."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

2 human-written examples

Apple declined to comment on the retraction.

The New York Times

"The corresponding author was contacted by email on August 27th regarding our decision, and was asked to comment on the retraction text and suggest changes.

Science Magazine

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

58 human-written examples

There was a telling comment left on the Retraction Watch blog last year from a graduate of the University of East London saying they only discovered the many questions that had been raised about one of their lecturers when someone put up posters linking to the blog (which is based in New York) in the toilets.

The Guardian

Annie Smith, a spokeswoman for the Irving-owned media holding company Brunswick News, said that no one at the newspaper would comment on the article or the retraction.

The New York Times

Ms. Rice then told Mr. Fleischer that he needed to correct his remarks, and worked with him on the retraction.

The New York Times

(Although Ninov's name appears on the retraction, he apparently refused to sign off on it).

Science Magazine

A spokeswoman for the bank could not immediately comment on the authenticity of these excerpts, but there is no sign that L'Express ever published a retraction of its article.

The New York Times

Comment on the N.Y.

The New Yorker

Comment on the Tel.

The New Yorker

Comment on the ideal taxicab.

The New Yorker

Comment on the Third Edition.

The New Yorker

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

In formal writing, ensure the request to "comment on the retraction" is phrased politely. Use phrases like "We would appreciate your comments on the retraction" to maintain a professional tone.

Common error

Don't simply ask someone to "comment on the retraction" without providing context. Offer background information or specific questions to guide their response. This ensures you receive relevant and useful feedback.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "comment on the retraction" functions as a request for an opinion or analysis regarding a formal withdrawal. As Ludwig AI confirms, the phrase is grammatically correct and commonly used. It prompts an individual to express their views on the circumstances, implications, or validity of the retraction.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

News & Media

50%

Science

50%

Formal & Business

0%

Less common in

Wiki

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Academia

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "comment on the retraction" is a grammatically sound and clear phrase used to solicit opinions or analysis regarding a formal withdrawal, as confirmed by Ludwig. Predominantly found in News & Media and Scientific contexts, it serves the purpose of gathering informed perspectives on the circumstances and implications of a retraction. While the phrase is grammatically correct, it appears infrequently in written English. Related phrases include "offer your perspective on the retraction" or "give your opinion on the retraction". When employing this phrase, it's advisable to provide context or specific questions to guide the respondent's comments and ensure relevant feedback.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

Give your opinion on the retraction

This alternative is more direct and focuses specifically on providing an opinion.

Share your thoughts on the retraction

This option is less formal and suggests a more casual sharing of opinions.

Discuss the retraction

This suggest an act of talking and sharing information regarding the retraction.

Provide feedback on the retraction

This suggests a focus on offering constructive criticism or evaluation.

Offer your perspective on the retraction

This alternative is a bit more formal and emphasizes providing a thoughtful opinion.

Weigh in on the retraction

This alternative suggests adding one's voice or opinion to an existing discussion.

React to the retraction

This alternative emphasizes expressing a reaction or emotional response.

Evaluate the retraction

This implies judging the quality or significance of the retraction.

Assess the retraction

This option highlights the act of evaluating the retraction's validity or impact.

Analyze the retraction

This emphasizes a deeper, more analytical examination of the retraction.

FAQs

What does it mean to "comment on the retraction"?

To "comment on the retraction" means to provide your opinion, analysis, or reaction to a formal withdrawal of a statement, publication, or claim. It involves expressing your views on the reasons for the retraction, its implications, or its validity.

How to use "comment on the retraction" in a sentence?

You can use "comment on the retraction" in a sentence like this: "The journal asked the lead researcher to "comment on the retraction" of their controversial study."

What are some alternatives to "comment on the retraction"?

Alternatives include "provide feedback on the retraction", "share your thoughts on the retraction", or "give your opinion on the retraction". The best choice depends on the context and the level of formality.

Is it appropriate to "comment on the retraction" in a formal setting?

Yes, it is appropriate to "comment on the retraction" in a formal setting, especially when your expertise or perspective is relevant. However, ensure your comments are professional, respectful, and based on evidence.