a real discipline

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "a real discipline" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used to refer to a field of study or practice that is recognized as legitimate and structured. Example: "Mathematics is often considered a real discipline that requires rigorous training and critical thinking skills."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

10 human-written examples

Country has a real discipline.

The Guardian - Film

"That creates a real discipline for people to get things done," he said.

The New York Times

"Parkour is a way of life, a real discipline," says Sébastien Foucan, one of its inventors.

The New York Times - Magazine

He used the scare quotes, presumably to indicate that he doubts political science is a real discipline.

The Economist

"The one thing about being a macro trader is that the P. & L. doesn't lie at the end of the day and there was a real discipline needed".

The New Yorker

And so that provides a real discipline in and of itself.

Forbes

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

50 human-written examples

Reports of six civilians from Ganfouda executed in cold blood by LNA fighters is evidence that Haftar's "military" is nothing more than a loose groups of untrained militants who don't have any real discipline and are prone to abuse and torture.

Huffington Post

And it's more likely that Ivanka would hop on QVC to sell handbags from inside the Oval Office than for Kellyanne Conway to face any real discipline for her free ad.

Vice

If it is a real subject, it must have a discipline.

Independent

Training for an event like a trialthlon takes real discipline, both of the mental and physical variety.

Huffington Post

And yet it is essentially a unit of the Pakistani military, which is an institution of real discipline and integrity.

The New Yorker

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using the phrase "a real discipline", ensure that the context clearly indicates that you are referring to a legitimate and structured field of study or practice. Avoid vague or ambiguous references.

Common error

Avoid applying the phrase "a real discipline" to activities or hobbies that lack the structure and rigor typically associated with established fields of study. Using it loosely can diminish the phrase's impact.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "a real discipline" functions as a noun phrase, typically used to characterize a specific area of study or practice as legitimate and structured. Ludwig AI confirms the phrase's acceptability, highlighting its role in emphasizing the rigor and validity of a field.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

50%

Science

33%

Formal & Business

17%

Less common in

Encyclopedias

0%

Wiki

0%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "a real discipline" is a grammatically correct and acceptable way to describe a legitimate and structured field of study or practice. Ludwig's analysis shows it is most commonly used in News & Media, often with a professional or neutral tone. While alternatives like "an actual discipline" or "a genuine discipline" exist, it's important to ensure the context warrants the emphasis on rigor and structure implied by the phrase. Avoid overgeneralizing its use to maintain its impact.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

an actual discipline

Replaces "real" with "actual", maintaining the core meaning but offering a slightly different emphasis.

a genuine discipline

Substitutes "real" with "genuine", highlighting the authenticity and validity of the discipline.

a true discipline

Replaces "real" with "true", emphasizing the adherence to standards and principles within the discipline.

an authentic discipline

Uses "authentic" instead of "real", stressing the unadulterated and original nature of the discipline.

a legitimate discipline

Replaces "real" with "legitimate", focusing on the recognized and accepted status of the discipline.

a valid discipline

Substitutes "real" with "valid", highlighting the sound reasoning and justification behind the discipline.

a concrete discipline

Replaces "real" with "concrete", emphasizing the tangible and practical aspects of the discipline.

a rigorous field of study

Replaces "discipline" with "field of study" and adds "rigorous" to emphasize the strictness and thoroughness involved.

a serious subject

Substitutes "discipline" with "subject", while "serious" emphasizes its importance and depth.

an established area of expertise

Replaces "discipline" with a more descriptive phrase, indicating a well-recognized and developed field.

FAQs

How can I use "a real discipline" in a sentence?

You can use "a real discipline" to describe a field of study or practice that requires rigorous training and adheres to specific methodologies. For example, "Mathematics is often considered "a real discipline" because of its structured principles and logical reasoning".

What's the difference between "a real discipline" and "a field of study"?

"A field of study" is a broader term, while ""a real discipline"" implies a more structured and recognized area of expertise with established methodologies and standards. Not all fields of study are necessarily considered real disciplines.

What can I say instead of "a real discipline"?

You can use alternatives like "a genuine discipline", "an authentic discipline", or "a legitimate discipline" depending on the context and the specific aspect you want to emphasize.

Is it appropriate to use "a real discipline" in informal conversation?

While grammatically correct, ""a real discipline"" might sound somewhat formal in casual conversation. In informal settings, simpler terms like "serious subject" or "proper field" might be more suitable.