a problematic proposition

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "a problematic proposition" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used when discussing an idea or suggestion that presents difficulties or challenges. Example: "The committee found that the proposed policy was a problematic proposition that could lead to unforeseen consequences."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

3 human-written examples

That's a problematic proposition, considering what the revelations the past couple of years have brought us with respect to privacy.

TechCrunch

Holdren had called it a "problematic proposition" that "we do not know whether it is 5000 barrels a day or 10,000 or 2000...

Science Magazine

In its most basic form it included the discussion of a problematic proposition, beginning with the presentation of the proposition, followed by a proof, a disproof and a solution, sometimes accompanied by a response to the opposing arguments (see our section 2.2).

SEP

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

55 human-written examples

"Don Giovanni," always a more problematic proposition, unfolded mostly in what appeared to be the nave of a cathedral, flanked by wall-to-wall confessionals.

The New York Times - Arts

Although at first glance that all sounds good and well, peace on the condition of reunification is a slightly more problematic proposition, unless the Kim dynasty and their entrenched crony elite are happy to pack their bags, move to Ecuador, and let South Korea sell off the country as prime Starbucks real estate.

Vice

Sachs and Katz are somewhat more hopeful, but their optimism is based on the politically problematic proposition that the United States can adopt wage and income policies similar to those in Scandinavian countries.

The New York Times

Certainly a Debatable Proposition.

Forbes

His method also requires the rigorous analysis of problematic propositions using the machinery of first-order logic.

SEP

Another example of a problematic sentence containing the disjunctive expression 'or' is the sophisma 'Every proposition or its contradictory opposite is true'.

SEP

He's a problematic interviewee.

The Guardian - Film

Distribution is a problematic word.

The Guardian - Music

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using the phrase "a problematic proposition", ensure the context clearly identifies the specific problem or challenge associated with the proposition. This adds clarity and strengthens your argument.

Common error

Avoid exaggerating the issues linked to "a problematic proposition". Present a balanced view, acknowledging potential benefits alongside the challenges to maintain credibility.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "a problematic proposition" functions as a noun phrase that describes a particular idea, plan, or statement. It acts as a subject, object, or complement within a sentence. As Ludwig AI states, this phrase denotes something that isn't straightforward and has potential issues.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

33%

Science

33%

Science

33%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Wiki

0%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "a problematic proposition" is a grammatically correct phrase used to describe an idea or suggestion that presents difficulties or challenges. While Ludwig AI confirms its usability, its frequency is uncommon, suggesting it is not the most prevalent way to express this concept. The phrase is most often found in news, science, and media contexts, indicating a neutral to professional tone. Consider alternatives like "a challenging proposition" or "a difficult undertaking" to adjust the nuance. When employing this phrase, ensure to clearly articulate the specific issues tied to the proposition.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

a challenging proposition

Emphasizes the difficulty and the need for effort to address the issue.

a difficult undertaking

Highlights the complexity and labor involved in attempting to carry out the proposition.

a troublesome matter

Focuses on the annoyance and potential for problems that the proposition presents.

a thorny issue

Implies that the proposition is complex and likely to cause disagreement or conflict.

a delicate situation

Suggests that the proposition requires careful handling to avoid negative consequences.

a contentious suggestion

Emphasizes the likelihood of argument and dispute surrounding the proposition.

a dubious plan

Expresses uncertainty or skepticism about the success or validity of the proposition.

a risky venture

Highlights the potential for loss or failure associated with the proposition.

a complex problem

Indicates that the proposition is intricate and requires deep analysis to solve.

a questionable approach

Casts doubt on the wisdom or appropriateness of the proposed method.

FAQs

How can I use "a problematic proposition" in a sentence?

You can use "a problematic proposition" to describe a suggestion or idea that presents difficulties or challenges. For example: "The committee found that the proposed policy was "a problematic proposition" that could lead to unforeseen consequences."

What are some alternatives to "a problematic proposition"?

Alternatives include "a challenging suggestion", "a troublesome idea", or "a difficult undertaking", depending on the specific nuance you wish to convey.

Is it better to say "problematic proposition" or "difficult proposition"?

While both are acceptable, "problematic proposition" emphasizes the presence of specific issues or complications, whereas "a difficult proposition" simply highlights the degree of effort required.

What makes a proposition "problematic"?

A proposition might be considered "problematic" if it faces significant obstacles, ethical concerns, practical limitations, or potential for negative consequences. It suggests that the idea requires careful consideration and potentially modification.