Used and loved by millions
Since I tried Ludwig back in 2017, I have been constantly using it in both editing and translation. Ever since, I suggest it to my translators at ProSciEditing.

Justyna Jupowicz-Kozak
CEO of Professional Science Editing for Scientists @ prosciediting.com
which initially emerged
Grammar usage guide and real-world examplesUSAGE SUMMARY
The phrase "which initially emerged" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used to refer to something that first appeared or was created at an earlier time, often in a historical or developmental context. Example: "The theory, which initially emerged in the early 20th century, has since evolved significantly."
✓ Grammatically correct
Alternative expressions(2)
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources
Similar Expressions
60 human-written examples
The B3LYP/6-31+G** B3LYP/6-31+G**ssigned PZ- to a single band at 1282 calculationsling), while MP2/6-31+G** positioned this bassigned284 cm−1 (no scaling), similar in shape, butonot asingled, as that which initially emerges at 1276 cm−1 in Figure 3.
Science
If Dylan's work in the 1960s was seen as bringing intellectual ambition to popular music, critics in the 21st century described him as a figure who had greatly expanded the folk culture from which he initially emerged.
Wiki
The macrocolony formed by strain W3110 can be divided into three distinct regions: the outer edge, which forms a narrow and smooth zone; a middle zone in which wrinkles initially emerge and which then becomes characterized by the appearance of concentric rings; and the inner wrinkled region, corresponding to the area in which cells were first inoculated onto the plate (Fig. 2).
Science
I'm still pretty conflicted on whether we should keep using the term, which I suspect initially emerged from the copyright wars and "digital rights management". But I think it will be tough to get rid of it, since it's become an encompassing shorthand for the range of human rights issues that can emerge in digitally networked spaces.
Academia
It has also been suggested that ESC resistance initially emerged in commensal Neisseria spp., which act as a reservoir of AMR genes that are easily transferred to gonococci through transformation, particularly in pharyngeal gonorrhoea [ 3, 7– 9, 42, 55– 55].
Science
This emphasis on acceptance initially emerged from the influential thought suppression literature, which demonstrates the sometimes paradoxical effects of attempts at thought control.
That team spirit initially emerged in Muhly's 2005 piece "Keep in Touch," which was written for Sirota and appears on "Speaks Volumes," Muhly's début album and the label's first release.
News & Media
The movement, which focused on the recording and distribution of music on low-quality cassette tapes, initially emerged in the 1980s.
Wiki
Reports of the payment, which was described in the confidentiality agreement between Fifa and the FAI as an "inducement", initially emerged last year, but it was confirmed for the first time by Delaney and then Fifa last week.
News & Media
Our knowledge of these superfamilies initially emerged from observations made concerning alcohol dehydrogenases of Drosophila and mammalian liver, which were seen to be clearly different [ 2, 3].
Science
Electrodeionization is an ionic separation technology that initially emerged ∼50 years ago.
Science
Expert writing Tips
Best practice
When using "which initially emerged", ensure the context clearly establishes the subsequent development or evolution of the subject. This provides a more complete picture for the reader.
Common error
Avoid using "which initially emerged" when the "initially" is already implied or obvious from the surrounding context. Redundancy can weaken the sentence's impact.
Source & Trust
60%
Authority and reliability
3.8/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested
Linguistic Context
The phrase "which initially emerged" functions as a relative clause, providing additional, non-essential information about the noun it modifies. According to Ludwig AI, this phrase is grammatically sound and usable in written English.
Frequent in
Science
0%
News & Media
0%
Formal & Business
0%
Less common in
Science
0%
News & Media
0%
Formal & Business
0%
Ludwig's WRAP-UP
The phrase "which initially emerged" serves as a relative clause, adding detail about the origin of a subject. While grammatically correct, its frequency is limited. The phrase tends towards formal and scientific contexts, aiming to provide a foundation for understanding the evolution or development of the topic at hand. Ludwig AI confirms its usability, advising careful consideration of redundancy to maintain concise and impactful writing.
More alternative expressions(6)
Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:
that first appeared
Emphasizes the point of first visibility or occurrence.
that began initially
Reiterates the temporal aspect of the commencement.
that originally arose
Focuses on the origin and development of something.
that was initially formed
Specifies the process of creation or formation.
which started out
Highlights the initial state or condition.
that was at first developed
Focuses on the early stages of development.
that sprung up initially
Implies a sudden or rapid emergence.
that was originally conceived
Emphasizes the initial idea or concept.
which historically began
Highlights the historical roots and commencement.
that commenced in its infancy
Metaphorically describes the beginning as an early stage of development.
FAQs
How can I use "which initially emerged" in a sentence?
Use "which initially emerged" to provide background information about the origins of something, for example: "The concept, which initially emerged in the 1980s, has since been refined."
What are some alternatives to "which initially emerged"?
You can use alternatives like "that first appeared", "that originally arose", or "that started out" depending on the specific nuance you want to convey.
Is it redundant to say "initially emerged"?
While not strictly incorrect, "initially emerged" can sometimes be redundant if the context already implies a beginning. Consider whether "first appeared" or another alternative might be more concise.
What is the difference between "which initially emerged" and "that initially emerged"?
The choice between "which" and "that" depends on whether the clause is nonrestrictive (providing extra information) or restrictive (essential to the meaning of the sentence). "Which" is typically used for nonrestrictive clauses, set off by commas, while "that" is used for restrictive clauses.
Editing plus AI, all in one place.
Stop switching between tools. Your AI writing partner for everything—polishing proposals, crafting emails, finding the right tone.
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Source & Trust
60%
Authority and reliability
3.8/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested