Used and loved by millions
Since I tried Ludwig back in 2017, I have been constantly using it in both editing and translation. Ever since, I suggest it to my translators at ProSciEditing.

Justyna Jupowicz-Kozak
CEO of Professional Science Editing for Scientists @ prosciediting.com
which have not been
Grammar usage guide and real-world examplesUSAGE SUMMARY
'which have not been' is a perfectly correct and usable phrase in written English.
It is used to refer to something that has not happened or been done in the past, usually in contrast to something else that has been done. For example: "Many businesses have already adopted energy efficient practices, which have not been adopted by some of their competitors."
✓ Grammatically correct
Science
News & Media
Academia
Alternative expressions(4)
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Human-verified examples from authoritative sources
Exact Expressions
60 human-written examples
Or claiming for quantum taxes which have not been incurred.
News & Media
Tells about U.S. quotas which have not been effective.
News & Media
Inspect the extracted spectra which have not been skysubtracted from any of your images.
Academia
The integration of Internet sources poses several challenges which have not been sufficiently addressed.
Academia
We describe several NN methods, some of which have not been widely used in computer vision.
Academia
Lectures which have not been published are so indicated in this bibliography.
Academia
Some experimental results revealed a few exceptions to this rule which have not been rationalised yet.
Science
Both hazard types require long-term planning horizons, which have not been readily or optimally adopted.
Science
At the same time, there are issues and tasks which have not been yet fully resolved.
Science
PAX8 and IMP3 are two markers which have not been well studied in the endocervix.
Science
Reforms to improve competitiveness, which have not been forthcoming, will be even more difficult to implement.
News & Media
Expert writing Tips
Best practice
When using "which have not been", ensure that the antecedent is clear and unambiguous. This improves readability and avoids confusion about what you're referring to.
Common error
Avoid using "that" when introducing a nonrestrictive clause. "Which", preceded by a comma, is appropriate for adding extra information that is not essential to the sentence's meaning. For example: The reports, which have not been verified, should be handled with caution.
Source & Trust
86%
Authority and reliability
4.6/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested
Linguistic Context
The phrase "which have not been" functions as a relative clause, specifically a nonrestrictive (or nonessential) clause. It provides additional, non-critical information about a noun or noun phrase already identified. Ludwig AI confirms its grammatical correctness.
Frequent in
Science
35%
News & Media
28%
Academia
12%
Less common in
Encyclopedias
3%
Formal & Business
2%
Reference
0%
Ludwig's WRAP-UP
In summary, "which have not been" is a versatile and grammatically sound phrase used to introduce nonrestrictive relative clauses. It appears frequently in science, news, and academic writing. According to Ludwig AI, the phrase is considered correct. When using this phrase, ensure that you precede it with a comma and that it adds extra, non-essential information. Alternatives like "that weren't" or "that haven't been" can be used depending on the context. Remember to avoid using "that" incorrectly when "which" is required for a nonrestrictive clause.
More alternative expressions(6)
Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:
that haven't been
Employs a contraction while maintaining a similar tense and structure.
that weren't
Uses a contraction and simpler verb form for a more informal tone.
which weren't
Uses a contraction and a simpler verb form for a more colloquial tone.
that were not
Omits "have" to form a simple past passive construction.
that have yet to be
Highlights that something is pending or expected.
which remain un-
Uses a prefix to indicate a lack of action or completion.
which are still to be
Emphasizes the future aspect of the non-completion.
that did not
Replaces the present perfect with a simple past construction.
that fail to be
Rephrases the concept using "fail" to express a lack of completion.
that lack
Substitutes a verb indicating absence for a passive construction.
FAQs
How to use "which have not been" in a sentence?
Use "which have not been" to introduce a nonrestrictive clause, providing additional information that is not essential to the sentence's main point. For instance: "The documents, which have not been reviewed, are still under consideration."
What's the difference between "which have not been" and "that have not been"?
"Which have not been" introduces a nonrestrictive clause, adding extra information. "That have not been" would introduce a restrictive clause, essential for defining the noun it modifies. Always use a comma before "which" in nonrestrictive clauses.
What can I say instead of "which have not been"?
You can use alternatives like "that weren't", "that haven't been", or "that were not" depending on the context and desired level of formality.
Is it correct to start a sentence with "which have not been"?
No, "which have not been" cannot start a sentence. It introduces a relative clause that must follow the noun or pronoun it modifies.
Editing plus AI, all in one place.
Stop switching between tools. Your AI writing partner for everything—polishing proposals, crafting emails, finding the right tone.
Table of contents
Usage summary
Human-verified examples
Expert writing tips
Linguistic context
Ludwig's wrap-up
Alternative expressions
FAQs
Source & Trust
86%
Authority and reliability
4.6/5
Expert rating
Real-world application tested