TV Guide reviewing team of Denise Martin and Kate Stanhope described it as "oddly mesmerizing, hilarious and kinda weird, even for Glee", and Amy Reiter of The Los Angeles Times wrote that "chipper and the sad were in perfect balance and the kitsch factor was high".
Votta could find no sense in its inclusion, and called it the "weirdest song on "Glee" since 'Run Joey Run, while Hankinson was harsher, and declared it to be his "least favorite Glee performance of all time".
Even Burt couldn't fix Mr. Schue and his weird obsession with his glee club.
It's like a weird cross between "Office Space" and "Glee".
Perhaps it's the Glee effect, but Blackpool seems less weird now than when it was first broadcast, in 2004.
This girl is on her own, conceivably sober, in a photo booth, pulling these abstract expressions of glee, and nobody thought it looked weird or unconvincing.
It evidently puts the taxpayer afoul of another one of those weird tax code provisions that make Internal Revenue Service agents rub their hands with glee.
It's one of those utterly weird numbers where they replace the names of everyone in the musical with the names of people on "Glee".
