this argument does not stand

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "this argument does not stand" is correct and usable in written English.
You can use it to express that you disagree with a particular argument. For example, "I disagree—this argument does not stand".

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

1 human-written examples

"When we are told that we must make the engine and then sell it for two pounds, from the economic point of view this argument does not stand - because it is going to change the dynamic business that we are managing.

BBC

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

59 human-written examples

Although rising health-care costs are a real issue, this argument doesn't stand up.

The New Yorker

So the superintendent can make that argument, but the argument doesn't stand".

The New York Times

Some academics suggest there are ways of ending a terrorist campaign other than negotiation, but a careful look at their examples shows the argument doesn't stand up.

The Guardian

Last year, the group was excoriated for overlooking Erroll Morris' "The Thin Blue Line". In both instances, committee members defended themselves by saying there were five better candidates than either "The Thin Blue Line" or "Michael & Me". That argument doesn't stand up to the scrutiny of the nominees.

Los Angeles Times

But even many critics of Europe's stance say that the president's argument does not stand up and that the dispute needs to be understood for what it is: a multibillion-dollar cross-Atlantic battle over agricultural trade.

The New York Times

That argument doesn't stand much scrutiny.

The Guardian - Opinion

The "it doesn't happen on Hackney Marshes" argument doesn't stand up though.

BBC

Ergo your argument doesn't stand out as no programme will ever win a majority.

BBC

Grothman's argument doesn't stand up to the facts.

Huffington Post

Frequencies, according to this line of argument, do not stand in the relations essential to pitch.

SEP

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Use "this argument does not stand" to directly challenge the validity or strength of a claim. It implies that the argument is weak, unsupported, or logically unsound.

Common error

While grammatically correct, "this argument does not stand" can sound overly formal in casual conversation. Consider using alternatives like "that doesn't make sense" or "that's not really true" for a more natural tone.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "this argument does not stand" functions as a declarative statement used to express disagreement or refutation of a claim. It's employed to assert that an argument is invalid, illogical, or unsupported, as confirmed by Ludwig AI and seen in examples across diverse sources.

Expression frequency: Common

Frequent in

News & Media

40%

Science

30%

Formal & Business

10%

Less common in

Encyclopedias

5%

Wiki

5%

Reference

5%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "this argument does not stand" is a phrase used to express disagreement or refutation, indicating that an argument is considered invalid or unsupported. Ludwig AI confirms its grammatical correctness and common usage across diverse sources, predominantly in news and media and scientific contexts. While the phrase is appropriate for neutral to formal settings, more informal alternatives exist for casual conversations. When using this phrase, ensure that it accurately reflects your assessment of the argument's weakness or lack of support. Furthermore, be mindful of overuse in less formal situations. Many equivalent phrases and alternative options exist.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

this argument is untenable

Replaces "does not stand" with "is untenable", suggesting the argument cannot be defended.

this argument is unsustainable

Indicates the argument cannot be maintained or supported over time.

this argument is invalid

Directly states the argument lacks logical validity.

this argument is flawed

Suggests the argument contains errors or weaknesses.

this argument is baseless

Implies the argument has no foundation or evidence.

this argument is groundless

Similar to baseless, indicating a lack of support or justification.

this argument doesn't hold up

Uses a more informal tone to express the argument's failure to withstand scrutiny.

this argument fails to convince

Focuses on the argument's inability to persuade.

this argument lacks merit

Suggests the argument has no value or worth.

this argument is refuted

Indicates the argument has been successfully disproven.

FAQs

What does "this argument does not stand" mean?

The phrase "this argument does not stand" means that a particular argument is considered invalid, illogical, or unsupported by evidence. It suggests that the argument is weak and cannot be justified.

What can I say instead of "this argument does not stand"?

You can use alternatives like "this argument is untenable", "this argument is invalid", or "this argument doesn't hold up" depending on the context.

Is "this argument does not stand" a formal or informal expression?

"This argument does not stand" is generally considered a formal expression. In informal settings, phrases like "that doesn't make sense" or "that's not true" might be more appropriate.

How to use "this argument does not stand" in a sentence?

You can use "this argument does not stand" to express disagreement with a claim. For example, "While the speaker presented compelling data, in my opinion, this argument does not stand when considering the broader context".