We investigated whether authors responded adequately to substantive criticism after publication and whether the critics and the editors were satisfied with the replies.
Dumbed down because the focus is on word choice rather than substantive criticism of the administration's handling of the incident; overblown because the administration's critics are trying to make an argument that the facts don't support.
As editors may lack sufficient knowledge about the particular research area or the methods used, they should also consider sending substantive criticisms and authors' replies for peer review, and it could be particularly valuable to use the critics as peer reviewers of authors' replies.
But Davis is smart and substantive — even many critics grant her that, save those who demean the petite blond with the label "Abortion Barbie".
Some of the critiques are purely aesthetic, but the most important ones are substantive: as planned, the critics argue, the memorial sells the supreme allied commander's greatness short.
Following these, I question here whether there exists sufficient substantive evidence given by critics (other than EFSA) to deny the validity of Seralini et al.'s findings.
The show proved that a pop musical could win over audiences with a substantive hit that pleased critics and theatergoers alike.
But there has been little substantive discussion between them, and critics of the drug laws had begun to fear that the issue was dead for the year.
What wasn't clear before last night was whether Obama shared King's discipline of addressing his critics on purely substantive grounds.
Aside from that, let's consider his substantive argument, based around three particular critics of - and victims of - tabloid intrusion: Hugh Grant, Steve Coogan and Max Mosley.
