substantive comments

USAGE SUMMARY

"substantive comments" is correct and usable in written English.
It is used to refer to comments or opinions that are meaningful or contain valuable information. For example, "The speaker provided substantive comments on the current state of the economy."

✓ Grammatically correct

Academia

News & Media

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

57 human-written examples

Some heavy posters, however, have consistently made substantive comments.

Harvard University

Mr. Sumwalt's remarks were the investigators' first substantive comments on the crash.

The New York Times

Perry's just good at brushing off substantive comments with bluster.8 47: Aha.

The Economist

Most users come to the forums to make significant substantive comments and do so.

Harvard University

I give the student a red-lined version of their draft with plenty of substantive comments.

University of California, Berkeley

They often flame one another and many heavy posters do not consistently make substantive comments.

Harvard University

Associates often complain of reviews with limited substantive comments, and minimal, if any, direction regarding career advancement.

Harvard Business Review

American officials made no substantive comments on the European rate cut today, but are sure to welcome it in their discussions with Mr. Lafontaine.

The New York Times

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

3 human-written examples

Neither man made any substantive comment before the talks began.

The Guardian

Meles made no substantive comment on inquiries regarding the liberalization of banking and telecommunications in Ethiopia.

The Guardian

Baseball officials and lawyers had no substantive comment on the ruling; they did not immediately pronounce contraction dead for 2002.

The New York Times - Sports

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When seeking feedback, specifically request "substantive comments" to encourage reviewers to focus on the core content and arguments rather than minor details.

Common error

Avoid prioritizing grammatical corrections over "substantive comments" when reviewing documents; ensure feedback addresses the core ideas and arguments.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "substantive comments" functions as a noun phrase, where the adjective 'substantive' modifies the noun 'comments'. It refers to comments that are meaningful, important, and address the core issues of a subject. Ludwig AI confirms this usage.

Expression frequency: Very common

Frequent in

Science

34%

News & Media

30%

Academia

23%

Less common in

Formal & Business

10%

Wiki

2%

Reference

1%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

The phrase "substantive comments" is a common and grammatically correct way to refer to meaningful and relevant feedback. As Ludwig AI confirms, it is used across various domains, including academia, news, and science, with the goal of eliciting or providing thoughtful input that addresses the core issues of a subject. When seeking or giving feedback, focusing on "substantive comments" ensures that the discussion goes beyond superficial corrections and contributes to a deeper understanding and improvement of the work. Related phrases such as "meaningful remarks" or "detailed critiques" can be used to add nuance to your communication.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

meaningful remarks

Focuses on the significance and depth of the comments.

significant observations

Emphasizes the importance and impact of the comments.

considerable feedback

Highlights the amount and value of the feedback provided.

detailed critiques

Concentrates on the thorough and analytical nature of the comments.

insightful commentary

Stresses the wisdom and understanding reflected in the comments.

valuable input

Underlines the worth and contribution of the comments.

pertinent suggestions

Emphasizes the relevance and helpfulness of the comments.

in-depth analysis

Focuses on the depth and comprehensiveness of the analytical comments.

thorough evaluations

Highlights the completeness and rigor of the evaluative comments.

constructive criticism

Highlights positive purpose to improve something in feedback form.

FAQs

What does "substantive comments" mean?

The term "substantive comments" refers to remarks or feedback that are meaningful, relevant, and address the core issues of a subject, rather than focusing on superficial aspects.

How can I ask for "substantive comments"?

When requesting feedback, be specific and state that you are looking for "substantive comments" on the content, arguments, or overall quality of the work. This helps direct the reviewer's attention to the most important aspects.

What are some alternatives to "substantive comments"?

You can use alternatives like "meaningful remarks", "significant observations", or "detailed critiques" depending on the context.

What is the difference between "substantive comments" and minor edits?

"Substantive comments" address the core content, arguments, and overall quality of a work, while minor edits typically focus on grammar, spelling, and formatting. "Substantive comments" aim to improve the overall quality and impact of the work, while minor edits enhance its presentation and readability.