Some critics also say that companies will shop for an accommodating oversight board after their research plans are rejected by more stringent reviewers.
After stringent reviewing, 22 papers wereacceptedforpresentationattheworkshop.Aftertheworkshop,thesepapers were revised on the basis of comments received both from the original reviewers and from discussions at the workshop itself.
This is partly explained by the other reviewer's more stringent inclusion criteria, which included a minimum of 50 subjects in each arm of the trial and an explicit statement that informed consent was obtained.
It should be noted that we in fact performed a more stringent randomization (as proposed by reviewer 3) that takes into account not only the number of sites in each protein, but also their positions regarding disordered regions, As can be seen, the two distribution are still very similar and therefore do not affect any of the conclusions.
However, Wikipedia's reviewers are strict, and the post-publication review process is stringent.
This could be due to more stringent enforcement during the peer review process, since the RSA method is less familiar to the reviewers of these journals.
3) edition of the journal Science, an interdisciplinary group is calling on scholars, funders, journal editors and reviewers to adopt more stringent and transparent standards to give social science research more credibility, substance and impact.
For the other dichotomous quality measures (Table 3), we were more stringent and required complete (3 of 3) reviewer agreement.
And it does not have Apple's stringent and sometimes inscrutable board of testers and reviewers, who can reject any app that, in their judgment, does not meet the company's technical or content standards.
We suggest that more stringent criteria should be applied by authors, publishers, and reviewers when assessing coverage of such important and universal topics.
For the additional quality measures (Table 3) we were even more stringent and required complete agreement from all 3 independent reviewers.
