In a ruling handed down late Thursday, Collins ruled that Rodriguez has a 4th Amendment right to challenge the shooting, which Collins said constituted a "seizure" by the Border Patrol because it stopped Jose from moving freely.
In a decision ruling handed down in April, the court ruled that the personnel department did not have grounds to exclude Mr. Zhang.
Two judges dismissed an application for a judicial review in a ruling handed down on Thursday.
A spokesman for Bondi said her office was still looking over the ruling handed down Friday.
The ruling, handed down yesterday, seemed certain to endanger many of the Transit Authority's testing practices.
The ruling, handed down July 5, was first reported Tuesday in The New York Law Journal.
He has analysed the impact of a judicial ruling handed down last year.
The outcome will be binding, according to a ruling handed down on Monday by the constitutional court.
The judge's ruling, handed down Friday, canceled a ban that would have remained in place for 20 more days.
Mr. Fogarty, too, lost his case in an Appellate Division ruling handed down in Albany last Thursday.
In the court's 342-page ruling, handed down on Tuesday, there was good news and bad news for all sides.
