What upsets Davis is the poor representation of the Rooney rule argument in the media.
A constraint of apriority certainly seems to rule argument (3) out as deductively valid, and rightly so.
A relatively new variation of the Golden Rule argument is being courtroom-tested by some prosecutors; it's called "channeling".
It's a version of the Golden Rule argument by transporting the jury into the victim's persona, inviting the jury to view the case through the victim's eyes, and begging the jury for sympathy and revenge.
"They have a golf rules argument to settle.
If what I am glad of is the kind of life I experience, in preference to there simply being less life of this kind in the world (cf. 1988c: 173–4), then, if universalization generates a golden-rule argument, it should indeed lead me to prescribe, ceteris paribus, creating other similar lives (unless it is the uniqueness of the life that I value).
end{aligned} (2.13 If one wants to estimate (E t)=frac{1}{2}d(x t),y(t))^2), summing up the two above inequalities, after a chain-rule argument for the composition of the function of two variables ((t,s mapsto frac{1}{2}d(x t),y(s))^2) and of the curve (tmapsto (t,t)), gives begin{aligned} frac{d}{dt} E t)le -2lambda E t).
Houlihan [ 48] for example articulates the 'keep the rules' argument as part of an agreement that has social weight.
But after ten years of AK rule such arguments are wearing thin.
"Over the past few months, lobbyists for the gas industry have pushed to carve large exemptions out of the rule with arguments about the cost of the rules and asserted difficulty of complying," she said.
