Sentence examples for rigorous reviewer from inspiring English sources

Statistics seem to be quite rigorous Reviewer #2: This manuscript examines the afferent inputs to dopamine neurons that project to selective areas of the CNS.

After a rigorous review process by expert reviewers overseen by the guest editors a total of 16 articles were accepted for publication.

Together with 21 Area Chairs and well over 300 reviewers, these Proceedings Track chairs led a scientific journal-level process of rigorous review to select 46 (19%) papers for oral presentation in Stockholm and publication in the Proceedings.

Dr. Lewin said that a journal editor needed to develop an intimate knowledge of his reviewers' strengths and weaknesses, and that "Nature and Science don't have the reputation for rigorous review".

We undertook a rigorous systematic review and meta-analysis using independent reviewers for data extraction and statistical analysis.

The plan, said Elie Seidman, the chief executive and co-founder, is to establish a big base of "rigorous and independent" reviews, each about 2,000 words, accompanied by reviewer-produced candid photographs of practically every nook of each hotel.

We are grateful to three anonymous reviewers for rigorous criticism and constructive comments, which helped us to improve the paper.

The proposals need development through open debate and subsequent rigorous implementation so that reviewers may determine the value of animal research to human health.

Our reviewers work hard to ensure a rapid, rigorous and fair peer review process of each manuscript.

But whether because the reviewers were not rigorous enough, or because Science's editors ignored their cautions, the result was a publication that leading experts felt had not been sufficiently scrutinized.

The improved reliability may also have stemmed from rigorous pilot testing, training of reviewers, increased familiarity with the RoB tool, and/or the set of decision rules specific to the SR.