The high proportion of review articles among the most-cited literature in some scientific fields suggests that reviews deserve more attention as to the impact they have on scientific progress.
For systematic reviewers we suggest that: (1) key trial(s) in a review deserve greater attention (2) systematic reviewers should check agreement of the most precise trial and the meta analysis.
I agree with Cox that peer review deserves our respect.
Hastings's review deserves a place in the now-classic book by Joanna Russ, How to Suppress Women's Writing.
Other approaches exist which, while not strictly within the scope of this review deserve highlighting.
Both books have received mostly negative reviews — largely deserved.
The book was not well-reviewed, and as was frequently the case, Manning felt slighted, feeling that she did not get the reviews she deserved.
A single chapter in this review is deserved by caloric restriction, the only nongenetic intervention that has consistently shown to slow the intrinsic rate of aging in mammals (Dirks and Leeuwenburgh 2006).
Its rave reviews were well deserved, and it joined Ben Goldacre's Bad Science as the Bookies' favourite at 3/1.
And if the press didn't have quite so strong a "praise or pan" incentive, Chris Christie might have woken up today, not to raves, but to the fairer reviews that he deserved.
