Suggestions(1)
Exact(5)
They deal in general with the review document or the reviewer style.
A disproportionate contribution of reviewer style would raise additional questions about current mechanisms of peer review.
Finally, to what extent does reviewer style influence recommendations?
In contrast to the evidence for a modest reviewer style effect, there was little evidence for a substantive Deputy Editor style effect on initial rejection decisions.
In addition, since publication of Siegelman's classic contribution[15], few analyses have addressed the relative contribution of article quality (hypothetically, an intrinsic property of the manuscript) vs. reviewer style (possibly ranging from highly skeptical to relatively uncritical) in generating recommendations to publish or reject.
Similar(54)
Which reviewers' styles appeal to you most, and why?
The fashion reviewers at Style.com describe his recent and less-sinister creations as "severe," "austere" and "ecclesiastical" — an upbeat assessment considering his enthusiasm for bitmap skulls.
One reviewer describes the style as a "fusion of by-the-numbers personal narrative and passionate, insightful commentary".
His great theme, in an age of academic specialisation and the McLuhanesque valuing of the medium over the message it conveyed, was the enduring worth of the old-style reviewer.
Regarding the album's musical style, NME reviewer Dave Hill wrote, "The drums, guitars, voice and production style are pressed scrupulously together in a murderous unity of surging, textured mood".
The book's "art is gloriously old-style," our reviewer, David Small, said.
Write better and faster with AI suggestions while staying true to your unique style.
Since I tried Ludwig back in 2017, I have been constantly using it in both editing and translation. Ever since, I suggest it to my translators at ProSciEditing.

Justyna Jupowicz-Kozak
CEO of Professional Science Editing for Scientists @ prosciediting.com