The EJNPN operates a double-blind peer-review system, where the reviewers do not know the names or affiliations of the authors and the reviewer reports provided to the authors are anonymous.
One reviewer reports that the phone is "very small and easy/painless to hide", but is concerned that this model isn't 100percentt plastic, so won't necessarily beat the BOSS.
The studies reviewer reported on 513 participants aged 6 y-21 y.
If one reviewer reports a level of certainty ≥5, while the remaining report <4, the reviewers will discuss the case and reconsider their scoring.
Moreover, the signed reviewer reports scored significantly higher on the same two questions as our open reports for BMC Infectious Diseases (Q3 regarding methodology and Q5 regarding constructiveness of comments).
For the included papers, a first reviewer reported on study aims, population, fatigue protocol, how fatigue was measured, and specification of outcomes and on findings.
The reviewer reports all seek to get the authors to focus the paper and address general issues, albeit from slightly different but overlapping perspectives.
The reviewer reported that the majority of recorded sessions showed evidence for the key CCBT processes being addressed including Cognitive Defusion, Acceptance, Present Moment Awareness and Values-based Action.
A 2×2 analysis of variance of the primary variable (change in quality score) was carried out to test the two hypotheses: 1, adding a statistical reviewer to the field expert peers and 2, suggesting reviewers reporting guidelines.
