regarding as to whether

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "regarding as to whether" is not correct in written English.
It is redundant because "regarding" and "as to" convey similar meanings, making the phrase unnecessarily complicated. Example: "The committee is still deliberating regarding as to whether to approve the new policy."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

Science

News & Media

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

1 human-written examples

For each signal we designed an ABX test, where A and B correspond to the male and female chorus recording (in random order), while each listener was asked to classify X as being closer to A or B regarding as to whether the male or female voices prevail in the recording.

EURASIP Journal on Audio, Speech, and Music Processing

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

59 human-written examples

One reservation regards as to whether there is a direct link or merely indirect links via for example lifestyle, which correlates with education.

Health Economics Review

Could you in your description also include your understanding of the waiver, and what that meant in regards as to how you could consider whether or not the secondary seal was really going to operate?

The New York Times

"Chelsea Lately" devotes a large portion of each show to a round-table discussion among Ms. Handler and a revolving cast of little-known comics who often display no real regard as to whether the audience is in on their jokes or not.

The New York Times

My experiences seem to confirm it: Throughout my early 20s, I found myself with guy after guy who thought it was no big deal to choke me, spank me, pull my hair, and/or jackhammer me with his dick, with no real regard as to whether or not I enjoyed his directionless convulsing.

Vice

Parents can be given much clearer results with regards as to whether or not their child will be affected.

European Journal of Human Genetics

CQUIN payments are made according to the number of patients risk assessed with no regard as to whether treatment procedures have been put into place.

BMJ Open

There have been debates regarding TL measurements as to whether different methods for TL measurement could affect the informativeness of TL measures for genetic and epidemiological studies involving TL [19], [20], [21].

Plosone

But such interpretations reverberates subversive religious conceptions like the aforementioned seemingly anarchistic Taoist teachings and that of other anti-authoritarian religious traditions creating a complex relationship regarding the question as to whether or not anarchism and religion are compatible.

Wikipedia

Regarding the question as to whether target selection follows or precedes target detection, we showed in Experiment 2, that the correlation between target detection rate and letter detection rate in the target was perfectly linear.

Plosone

Nevertheless, the interviewed PCPs were divided regarding the question as to whether guidelines should be developed.

BMC Family Practice

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Avoid using the phrase "regarding as to whether" in formal writing. Opt for more concise alternatives like "regarding whether" or "concerning whether" to improve clarity and grammatical correctness.

Common error

The mistake is using "regarding as to whether" when a simpler phrase like "regarding whether" is sufficient. The "as to" is unnecessary and adds no value.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "regarding as to whether" functions as a connector introducing a conditional clause. It sets the stage for considering different possibilities or options. However, it is considered redundant.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

Science

47%

News & Media

26%

Academia

17%

Less common in

Formal & Business

5%

Wiki

3%

Encyclopedias

2%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, while the phrase "regarding as to whether" appears in various contexts, particularly scientific and news-related sources, Ludwig AI flags it as incorrect due to its redundant nature. It is grammatically questionable. The phrase's purpose is to introduce a question of conditionality or consideration, but it can be more clearly and concisely expressed using alternatives such as "regarding whether" or "concerning whether". For polished and professional writing, these shorter options are highly recommended. Some authoritative sources still use it, but with some caveats in mind.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

Regarding whether

Omits "as to", making the phrase more concise while retaining its meaning.

Concerning whether

Replaces "regarding" with "concerning", offering a similar meaning without the redundancy.

As to whether

Focuses directly on the conditional aspect, removing "regarding" for brevity.

About whether

Uses "about" instead of "regarding", providing a slightly less formal alternative.

On the question of whether

Expands the phrase to emphasize the inquiry, adding formality.

In regard to whether

Maintains a formal tone while streamlining the original phrase by removing "as to".

With respect to whether

Offers a more formal and polite tone, suitable for professional contexts.

Considering if

Simplifies the phrase by using "considering" and "if" instead of "regarding as to whether".

Looking at whether

Presents a more direct and active consideration of the condition.

In terms of whether

Frames the condition within a specific scope or perspective.

FAQs

What's wrong with using "regarding as to whether"?

The phrase "regarding as to whether" is redundant. "Regarding" and "as to" serve similar functions, making the phrase unnecessarily wordy. It's better to use just "regarding whether" or "concerning whether".

What can I say instead of "regarding as to whether"?

You can use alternatives like "regarding whether", "concerning whether", or "as to whether" depending on the context.

Is "regarding as to whether" grammatically correct?

No, "regarding as to whether" is not considered grammatically correct in formal writing. It includes redundant elements that make the phrase unnecessarily complex.

How to use "regarding whether" instead of "regarding as to whether" in a sentence?

Instead of "The study is deliberating regarding as to whether to approve the new policy", you can say "The study is deliberating regarding whether to approve the new policy".