But, not only using pairwise sequence comparisons, but also profile-profile analysis (this referees' analysis) fail to detect any significant homology, even when the search is restricted to the putatively homologous region originally identified by Rassow et al (ref. [ 16]).
We agree with the referee that the analysis based on the first author has, together with pros, some cons; for this reason we think that it will be useful to complement this analysis with analyses that include all authors.
We predicted, based on previous research involving the analysis of referees' decisions, that there would be systematic expertise-based differences in the decision-making accuracy (Catteeuw et al., 2009; Gilis et al., 2008; Hancock & Ste-Marie, 2013; Mascarenhas et al., 2005).
Fifty-eight refereed articles remained for analysis.
If, on the other hand, the consensus is that the manuscript is, in principle, acceptable for publication in eLife, but requires additional experiments or analysis, the referees work with each other to identify the additional studies that are required for acceptance.
Referee: Massimo Busacca (Switzerland) Some analysis of the team news which I've cut and pasted straight from the wires, making absolutely no attempt whatsoever to change a single word.
The evaluation method (peer review or bibliometric analysis) and the referee mix (whether men or women) do not disadvantage women.
bAn anonymous referee suggested including in the analysis estimates of "implicit prices" provided by hedonic price modeling as done by Deselnicu et al. (2013).
Post-match analysis showed that referee Oliver had erroneously awarded the corner kick from which Gillingham's goal had been scored, as the ball had in fact come off Barcham and therefore a goal kick should instead have been awarded to Shrewsbury.
We agree with the referee that the term "correlation analysis' can create confusion.
