redundant comments

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "redundant comments" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used to describe remarks or statements that are unnecessary because they repeat information already provided. Example: "During the meeting, several participants made redundant comments that did not add any new insights to the discussion."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

2 human-written examples

The same people hog the floor with pointless, redundant comments, while others say nothing.

The New York Times

Furthermore, the possibility of omitting redundant comments and concretizing comments before noting them by the tutor, or the more limited space may have contributed to the lower number and/or the higher quality of the comments in the paper based group.

Advances in Health Sciences Education

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

56 human-written examples

The Village Voices Jessica Winter called Madonna's voice "redundant" and commented that "she ironizes 'the American dream' only to pitch woo at her English husband and articulate a vague yet fiery frustration with her outrageously privileged station in the world".

Wikipedia

If the decision is favourable, the authors receive a decision letter listing the points that need to be addressed in the revised version of the paper: authors are not sent all the referee reports in their entirety and do not, therefore, have to respond to redundant or conflicting comments in the reports.

eLife

Comments are labelled (flamebait, troll, redundant, insightful, interesting, informative, funny etc) and rated, and Slashdotters can vote them up or down.

The Guardian - Tech

One can only receive so many death threats, insults, challenges and disgusting comments before it all becomes redundant and uninspiring.

Huffington Post

Also, like New Yorkers, residents of the Internet do not suffer fools, or mince words in belittling them, as anyone who has contributed a redundant post to Metafilter, or an earnest comment to Gawker, can attest.

The New York Times

The majority of the participants who gave a comment judged the pictogram as redundant (9/4), confusing and even not suitable to the needs of elderly people (8/1).

BMC Geriatrics

The reviewer also comments on the possible advantages of redundant genes.

Biology Direct

That is a welcome 'reverse ferret' from her previous comment, which suggested that the Royal Charter was redundant".

The Guardian

Moderation applies either −1 or +1 to the current rating, based on whether the comment is perceived as either normal, offtopic, insightful, redundant, interesting, or troll (among others).

Wikipedia

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When revising written work, actively seek and remove "redundant comments" to ensure clarity and conciseness. Focus on presenting information in the most streamlined and efficient manner.

Common error

Avoid using excessive qualifiers before "redundant comments", such as "very redundant comments" or "extremely redundant comments". The term "redundant" already implies unnecessary repetition, making further qualification superfluous.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "redundant comments" functions as a noun phrase where the adjective "redundant" modifies the noun "comments". It describes the nature of the comments, indicating that they are repetitive or unnecessary. This usage aligns with Ludwig's analysis that the phrase is grammatically sound and suitable for use.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

33%

Science

33%

Wiki

17%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Academia

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "redundant comments" is a grammatically correct and understandable way to refer to unnecessary or repetitive remarks. While not overly common, according to Ludwig, it appears in diverse contexts, particularly news and science, and carries a neutral-to-formal register. When using this phrase, avoid overuse of qualifiers, and consider alternatives like "superfluous remarks" or "unnecessary remarks" for variety. Recognizing and eliminating redundancy enhances the clarity and impact of communication.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

superfluous remarks

Replaces "redundant" with "superfluous", emphasizing the excessiveness of the remarks.

unnecessary remarks

Uses "unnecessary" instead of "redundant", highlighting that the remarks were not needed.

repetitive comments

Focuses on the repetitive nature of the comments.

pointless remarks

Highlights the lack of purpose in the comments.

gratuitous comments

Indicates the comments were uncalled for.

excessive commentary

Shifts the focus to the overall commentary being excessive.

needless comments

Emphasizes the lack of necessity of the comments.

unwarranted remarks

Suggests the remarks were not justified.

otiose comments

Uses a more formal synonym for redundant, 'otiose', implying the comments are idle or useless.

tautological statements

Focuses on the tautological or circular nature of the comments.

FAQs

What does "redundant comments" mean?

The phrase "redundant comments" refers to remarks or statements that are unnecessary because they repeat information that has already been shared, adding no new value to a discussion or piece of writing.

How can I identify "redundant comments" in my writing?

Look for sentences or phrases that express the same idea multiple times or that reiterate information that is already evident from the context. Removing these redundancies will make your writing more concise and impactful.

What are some alternatives to saying "redundant comments"?

You can use alternatives such as "superfluous remarks", "unnecessary remarks", or "repetitive comments" to convey a similar meaning depending on the specific context.

Is it always bad to have "redundant comments"?

While redundancy is generally discouraged in formal writing and discussions, there may be situations where repeating information can be useful for emphasis or clarity, particularly when dealing with complex or easily misunderstood topics. However, be mindful of overusing it.