After a reasonable seizure-free period, discontinuation of antiepileptic drugs (AED) is usually decided in epileptic patients despite the risk of seizure recurrence.
Opponents of Carnivore have said since the system first became public earlier this year that it raises troubling questions about what constitutes a reasonable search and seizure of electronic data.
A seizure reasonable as to one type of material in one setting may be unreasonable in a different setting or with respect to another kind of material.
What is reasonable "search and seizure" here for law enforcement?
Denise Gilman, director of the Immigration Clinic at the University of Texas Law School, said that the action was likely unlawful, noting that it seemed to violate the Fourth Amendment ensuring reasonable search and seizure as well as the Fifth Amendment, which protects due process for individuals.
We must frequently decide, for example, what are "reasonable" searches and seizures under the Fourth Amendment.
And this despite the long line of decisions in this Court recognizing as consistent with the restrictions of the Fourth Amendment the power of law-enforcement officers to make reasonable searches and seizures as incidents to lawful arrests.
The District Court denied th motion after a hearing, holding that the seizure was reasonable and hence constitutional.
In a separate dissent Mr. Justice Black, joined by The Chief Justice and Mr. Justice Stewart, also emphasized that the ultimate test of legality under the Fourth Amendment was whether the search and seizure were reasonable.
However, by applying the basic principles of epilepsy surgery selection (i.e., convergence of multiple lines of localizing evidence) to this population, patients with a reasonable likelihood of good seizure control can be identified.
And now, he wrote, "reasonable suspicion justifying the seizure of citizens will be found even if police officers are mistaken concerning the law as long as their testimony includes magic words such as 'I thought..
