He also suggests that when you're hiring, make it a peer review exercise, so in effect, everyone hires everyone else.
In response, two management workers explained that management in consultation with frontline workers agreed to sacrifice all incentives to workers and rather use the money to buy essential items, which were required for a peer review exercise.
Research in this area has shown that collaboration in the form of peer-review exercises can improve writing outcomes.
Therefore, although much public debate about peer review focuses on journal peer review, our examination pertains to more broadly defined peer-review exercises.
I was extremely pleased to have modernized and improved the curriculum in a way that also emulates modern scientific publishing practices; I feel the peer-review exercise both improves the quality of the students' written projects and introduces them to the important process of peer-review that many will encounter later in their careers.
When I asked several students whether they thought the peer-review exercise helped them, they indicated several benefits: it "forced" them to prepare a rough draft several days in advance of the final due date, the comments were usually helpful, and they found the discussions helpful as well.
Course activities include in-class debates, a peer-review exercise supervised by a senior scientist, observing research with animals and human participants, and interpreting science ethics commentaries in national newspapers.
After participating in a group peer-review exercise at a workshop presented by Academic Medicine and MedEdPORTAL editors at the 2015 Association of American Medical Colleges Medical Education Meeting, the authors realized that the way their work group reviewed a manuscript was very different from the way by which they each would have reviewed the paper as an individual.
In a survey, a vast majority of peer review participants assessed the exercise to be useful, one fifth made substantial changes to their strategy processes after receiving feedback, while half of participants introduced some smaller changes after the workshop (Midtkandal and Hegyi, 2014).
Furthermore, open peer review improves constructiveness of peer reviewer comments.
Take peer review as a prime example.
