of what comprised

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "of what comprised" is not correct in standard written English.
It is likely intended to convey the idea of describing the components or elements of something, but the phrasing is awkward and unclear. Example: "The report details the findings of what comprised the study's sample population."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

Science

News & Media

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

2 human-written examples

A striking contrast was presented by France, which would not budge from an astringent and classic definition of what comprised the secular: a strict separation of religion from the state, or, for that matter, from the public domain.

The Guardian

The details of what comprised these two categories are given in notes to Table 3.

Health Policy and Planning

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

58 human-written examples

Thus, much of what comprises this ceiling is invisible.

The Guardian - Opinion

"Hopefully, Manhattan can keep expanding its definition of what comprises Manhattan".

The New York Times

"New York is easily the largest state in which anyone has attempted to answer the question of what comprises adequacy and, because of its visibility, what results from these studies will be the shot heard round the nation".

The New York Times

What the US, Britain and other western countries involved in Afghanistan since 2001 have failed to realise is that corruption goes to the heart of what comprises the Afghan "state", said an influential Afghan analyst who asked not to be identified.

The Guardian - Opinion

Even if Brooks is the kind of writer who makes you want to preface your sentences with the phrase "Brooks isn't wrong to point out," Brooks isn't wrong to point out that the examination of what comprises a moral life, an examination that came as second nature to his subjects, has fallen out of cultural favor, at least in the overachieving circles of the meritocracy.

The New Yorker

His point is that the statistical language models (SLMs) that are necessary for accurate automated speech recognition are only the beginning of what comprises a natural, multi-modal, mixed initiative user interface.

TechCrunch

In conjunction with statistical training and parsing techniques, this loosening of grammar leads to a rather different conception of what comprises a grammatically flawed sentence: It is not necessarily one rejected by the grammar, but one whose analysis requires some rarely used rules.

SEP

Although Nussbaum, Ravitch and Hirsch have very different views of what comprises a liberal education, they do agree that such an education is crucial for a polity of citizens rather than of subjects.

Huffington Post

Another limitation is the current lack of a standard definition of what comprises a 'normal microbiota'.

BMJ Open

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Avoid using the phrase "of what comprised". Instead, use grammatically correct alternatives such as "of what constituted", "of what consisted of", or "of what made up" for clarity and accuracy.

Common error

Do not use "comprised of" when "comprised" alone is sufficient. The correct usage is "the city comprised several districts" or "the city was comprised of several districts". Using "of what comprised" is grammatically unsound.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "of what comprised" attempts to function as a prepositional phrase, often intended to specify the components or elements of something. However, it is considered grammatically incorrect and using it is not advisable, as highlighted by Ludwig.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

Science

50%

News & Media

50%

Formal & Business

0%

Less common in

Encyclopedias

0%

Wiki

0%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "of what comprised" is grammatically incorrect and should be avoided in standard English writing. As highlighted by Ludwig, more appropriate alternatives include "of what constituted", "of what consisted of", or "of what made up". While examples can be found in both scientific and news media, the phrase's incorrectness undermines its clarity and communicative effectiveness. Therefore, it is best to opt for grammatically sound alternatives to accurately convey the intended meaning.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

of what constituted

Replaces 'comprised' with 'constituted' providing a more standard and grammatically sound alternative.

of what consisted of

Uses 'consisted of' instead of 'comprised' resulting in a clearer and more conventional expression.

of what made up

Substitutes 'comprised' with 'made up' offering a more informal and easily understandable option.

of what it included

Changes the structure to focus on inclusion rather than composition.

detailing its components

Shifts from composition to a description of components.

specifying its elements

Emphasizes the specification of elements instead of the overall composition.

identifying its constituents

Focuses on identifying the individual parts that make up the whole.

explaining its composition

Replaces the phrase with a more direct explanation of the structure.

describing what it contained

Focuses on the contents rather than the composition itself.

outlining its makeup

Offers an outline of the structure instead of detailing its composition.

FAQs

What are some alternatives to "of what comprised"?

Better alternatives include "of what constituted", "of what consisted of", or "of what made up", depending on the context. These options are grammatically correct and more widely accepted.

Is it grammatically correct to say "of what comprised"?

No, "of what comprised" is not considered grammatically correct in standard English. It's best to use alternative phrasing for clarity and correctness.

How can I use "constituted of" correctly?

While "constituted of" might seem similar, a better option is to use alternatives as described above. Alternatively, consider saying, the recipe "consisted of" flour, sugar and eggs.

Why is "of what comprised" considered incorrect?

The phrasing is awkward and doesn't follow standard English grammar rules. Using more common alternatives like "made up of" or "consisted of" improves clarity and grammatical correctness.