meaningful comments

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "meaningful comments" is correct and usable in written English.
You can use it when referring to comments that provide significant insight, feedback, or value in a discussion or written work. Example: "The professor encouraged students to provide meaningful comments on each other's essays to foster a constructive learning environment."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Academia

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

6 human-written examples

You must give people enough information to enable them to make meaningful comments and suggestions.

The Guardian

In this paper, we propose a Two-stage Intelligent Notification Mechanism (TINM) for blogging systems to carry out intelligent comment notification, so that the blogger only receives meaningful comments.

Expert Systems with Applications

Other messages that staffers tend to disregard include tweets and Facebook posts (less out of dismissiveness than because of the difficulty of determining if they come from constituents), online petitions (because they require so little effort that they aren't seen as meaningful), comments submitted through apps like Countable, and mass e-mails that originate from the Web sites of advocacy groups.

The New Yorker

We would also like to add acknowledging of Prof. Steven Ingebritsen (U.S. Geological survey) and Prof. Andre Revil (University of Savoie Mont-Blanc) for their meaningful comments, revisions and advices that help us to improve this manuscript.

Earth, Planets and Space

See if you can get your kids to pick out the kinds of statements that are attention-getting vs. meaningful comments about what policies the candidates would institute if elected.

Huffington Post

Of these, three out of eight had biochemical control at 6 12 months (PSA <0.2 ng ml−1 in two out of eight and <0.5 ng ml−1 in one out of eight), one out of eight failed again (positive on biopsy) and underwent salvage external beam radiotherapy and four out of eight had insufficient follow-up to make meaningful comments about PSA kinetics (<6 months).

British Journal of Cancer

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

54 human-written examples

As draft followed draft, I struggled to make any meaningful comment.

The Guardian - Lifestyle

The United States could do so as well, though the Trump administration made little meaningful comment about the impasse on Monday.

The Washington Post

"How do you write a meaningful comment on such rich, complex, still undiscovered work, without making a critical fool of yourself?" he wrote.

The New York Times - Arts

To include Nicola Sturgeon with Donald Trump and Boris Johnson in a group of "the biggest liars of all" is almost laughable and perhaps tells us more about Nick Cohen than being in any way meaningful comment.

The Guardian - Opinion

The establishment of procedures to permit companies reasonable time to review and provide meaningful comment on draft proxy advisory firm recommendations, including the opportunity to present (in person or telephonically) to the person responsible for the recommendation.

Harvard University

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When seeking feedback, encourage specific and "meaningful comments" by asking targeted questions. This helps respondents focus on providing insightful and relevant input rather than generic praise.

Common error

Avoid asking for general "comments" without providing context. This often leads to superficial or unhelpful feedback. Instead, specify the areas where you need "meaningful comments" to ensure the feedback is actionable.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "meaningful comments" functions as a noun phrase, where "meaningful" is an adjective modifying the noun "comments". It describes the quality or nature of the comments, emphasizing their significance and value. As Ludwig AI states, the phrase is correct and usable in written English.

Expression frequency: Uncommon

Frequent in

News & Media

40%

Science

30%

Academia

15%

Less common in

Wiki

5%

Formal & Business

5%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "meaningful comments" is a phrase used to describe feedback or remarks that are significant, insightful, and valuable. Ludwig AI confirms its correctness and usability in written English. While not extremely common, the phrase finds its place in news, science, and academic contexts, emphasizing the importance of thoughtful and relevant input. To ensure you elicit "meaningful comments", provide clear guidelines and prompts, and when giving feedback, strive for specificity and actionability.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

insightful remarks

Replaces "comments" with "remarks", emphasizing the depth and understanding conveyed.

valuable feedback

Substitutes "comments" with "feedback", highlighting the usefulness and importance of the input.

significant observations

Uses "observations" instead of "comments", focusing on the noteworthiness and impact of the remarks.

constructive criticisms

Emphasizes the helpful and improvement-oriented nature of the comments.

substantive input

Replaces "comments" with "input", stressing the considerable content and worth of the contribution.

thoughtful considerations

Highlights the careful and reflective nature of the comments.

pertinent remarks

Focuses on the relevance and appropriateness of the comments to the topic at hand.

relevant insights

Combines the ideas of relevance and deep understanding in the comments.

impactful feedback

Emphasizes the powerful effect and influence of the feedback given.

worthwhile contributions

Highlights the value and benefit provided by the comments.

FAQs

How can I elicit more "meaningful comments"?

Provide clear guidelines or a rubric to those offering feedback. Specific prompts help focus their attention and encourage more thoughtful and constructive responses.

What are some alternatives to "meaningful comments"?

You can use alternatives like "insightful remarks", "valuable feedback", or "significant observations" to express similar ideas.

In what contexts is "meaningful comments" most appropriate?

This phrase is suitable in various contexts, including academic, professional, and public discussions, where in-depth and valuable feedback is desired. It's particularly useful when you want to emphasize the importance of thoughtful and relevant input.

How do I ensure I'm providing "meaningful comments"?

Focus on providing specific, actionable, and relevant feedback. Frame your comments in a way that helps the recipient understand the impact of their work and how they can improve. Avoid generic praise or criticism.