Ai Feedback
Exact(5)
An explanation of why the conclusions are interesting and who (outside the obvious) will find the paper worth reading can make a compelling case to the editor to send the manuscript out for peer review.
A Russian Academy of Science nanotechnology specialist sends a manuscript out for review, gets critical comments and suggestions for revisions, decides the reviewers are idiots who do not understand his work, and publishes the article in Russian in a journal where everyone knows him.
"We reject something on the order of 90% plus, and that's the same for Nature, Cell, and Science," says Robert Shields, an editor at PLoS Biology, and editorial rejections--rejections by the editor without sending the manuscript out for review--make up the majority of those rejections.
For the journals that sent the manuscript out for independent peer review, this 'experiment' illustrates that many peer reviewers may not take a careful, detailed, and critical look at a manuscript that is sent to them.
19 In our study it took on average between 15 and 20 minutes to review each manuscript against the CONSORT checklist items; a task that could be done internally by a trained editorial assistant (internal peer review) before sending a manuscript out for external peer review.
Similar(55)
Korda had the knack for conjuring manuscripts out of these situations, and the sportsman-like brio to look forward to the next one.
The journal has also "formally removed the review from the record, and have sent the manuscript out to a new editor for re-review.
Most submissions transferred to Cancer Medicine from partnering journals will be assessed using the original peer-review reports from those journals; however, the Editor-in-Chief will critically review these peer-review reports and may choose to send manuscripts out for additional double-blind review.
He kayaked into Poland to smuggle Lech Walesa's manuscript out.
G. Send your manuscript out.
Read the manuscript out loud.
Write better and faster with AI suggestions while staying true to your unique style.
Since I tried Ludwig back in 2017, I have been constantly using it in both editing and translation. Ever since, I suggest it to my translators at ProSciEditing.

Justyna Jupowicz-Kozak
CEO of Professional Science Editing for Scientists @ prosciediting.com