Everything he had, he invested in Pakistan, giving livelihoods to tens of thousands, improving the economy.
But it dismayed environmentalists and people who owe their livelihoods to fisheries and tourism.
Every family in Katine relies on farming for their livelihoods to some degree.
Many of the sites, the officials noted, are near water, which provided transportation and livelihoods to early industry and settlements.
They have livelihoods to defend, even if the challenge to authority highlights golf's enslavement to the money list.
"The conservative movement's mission has become providing comfortable professional livelihoods to literally hundreds of people," David Frum told me recently.
They said they owed their livelihoods to Sheik Sattar, because his men had forced jihadists off the roads.
Women are particularly disadvantaged by loss of land; many are forced to abandon their traditional livelihoods to become plantation labourers.
Thousands in Naples owed their livelihoods to either Byzantine political patronage or to the Camorra, or both.
But there is little prospect, officials here admit, for other livelihoods to support the growing hillside population.
Raising a dispute over land and livelihoods to a metaphysical plane renders it insoluble, which I am certain is not Mr. Carroll's intention.
