it has collapsed in

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "it has collapsed in" is not correct in standard written English.
It may be intended to describe something that has fallen inward or failed, but the phrasing is awkward and unclear. Example: "The structure was deemed unsafe after it has collapsed in during the storm."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

News & Media

Wiki

Science

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

4 human-written examples

But now it has collapsed in flames.

The Economist

In Rome, he says, there is so much history that it has "collapsed in on itself and become irrelevant".

The Guardian - Arts

"Chennai is stinking and it is shocking to see how it has collapsed in the last 48 hours," said Anant Raghav, a professor at the University of Madras.

The Guardian

Even as it has collapsed in private industry, it has remained strong in government ever since John F. Kennedy's 1963 decision to allow the organization of federal workers (an initiative rapidly followed by most states).

Forbes

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

55 human-written examples

Sets from the previous film were reused, having survived three hurricanes, although the main pier had to be rebuilt as it had collapsed in November.

Wikipedia

We are going through a dark night of the soul akin to September 11, but without the kinship, without the expression of our soul-disturbing grief, without a resounding public acknowledgment that the twin towers of capitalism and globalization as we have known it have collapsed in a rubble all around us.

Huffington Post

The cost of the banking crisis to private investors – many of them first-time investors – is spelled out by new research showing that the near £1,500 windfall of shares handed to millions of former members of Halifax when it converted from a building society has collapsed in value to £38.

The Guardian - Business

FOUR months after it was inaugurated, the American-backed road map has collapsed in blood.

The Economist

Party identification has collapsed in Indonesia".

The New York Times

The region has collapsed in on itself.

The New Yorker

The team has collapsed in confidence and in execution.

The New York Times - Sports

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When describing a structural failure, prefer more precise verbs like "cave in", "fall in", or "crumble" instead of "collapsed in" for improved clarity and grammatical correctness.

Common error

Be mindful of redundancy. Using "collapsed in" can sometimes be redundant, as "collapse" already implies an inward or downward movement. Instead, focus on the specific manner of collapsing to enhance your description.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "it has collapsed in" functions as part of a predicate, describing the state or condition of a subject. However, it is not considered the most grammatically correct or stylistically preferred way to express this idea, as noted by Ludwig.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

News & Media

60%

Wiki

20%

Science

20%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Social Media

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, while the phrase "it has collapsed in" appears in various sources, Ludwig AI suggests that it's not the most grammatically sound or stylistically preferred option. It aims to describe a state of failure or structural breakdown. More precise and clearer alternatives such as "it has fallen in" or "it has caved in" are recommended for improved writing. Its usage frequency is rare, and while it can be found in news and media, exercising caution and opting for better alternatives is advisable.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

it has fallen in

This alternative replaces "collapsed in" with "fallen in", which is grammatically sound and implies something caving inwards.

it has caved in

This option replaces "collapsed in" with "caved in", suggesting an inward collapse, making it more specific.

it has crumbled

This alternative emphasizes the breaking or disintegrating aspect of the collapse.

it has disintegrated

This suggests a more complete and thorough breakdown than "collapsed in".

it has broken down

This phrase is less specific about the nature of the collapse but conveys a failure of function or structure.

it has failed

A general term for not succeeding or functioning correctly, applicable in many contexts where "collapsed in" might be used.

it has declined

This suggests a gradual deterioration rather than a sudden collapse.

it has deteriorated

Similar to "declined", but emphasizes the worsening condition over time.

it has imploded

Implies a collapse inward, often used in a more technical or dramatic context.

it has given way

Suggests that something has yielded under pressure, leading to a collapse.

FAQs

Is "it has collapsed in" grammatically correct?

While occasionally found in writing, the phrase "it has collapsed in" is generally considered grammatically awkward. Better alternatives include "it has fallen in" or "it has caved in".

What's a better way to say something has "collapsed in"?

Depending on the context, you can use phrases such as "it has fallen in", "it has caved in", or "it has crumbled". These alternatives provide clearer and more grammatically sound ways to express the idea of something collapsing.

When can I use "collapsed in"?

While not strictly incorrect, "collapsed in" isn't the most polished phrasing. Consider rewriting the sentence using stronger verbs like "it has imploded" or "it has given way" for better clarity and impact.

Are there situations where "collapsed in" is preferred over other alternatives?

In most situations, no. Alternatives such as "it has fallen in" or "it has caved in" are typically clearer and more grammatically sound. The choice depends on the specific nuance you want to convey.