is proportionate for

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "is proportionate for" is not correct in standard written English.
It is typically used to describe a relationship where one thing is balanced or corresponds appropriately to another, but the phrasing is awkward. Example: "The budget allocation is proportionate for the project's scale and requirements."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

News & Media

Science

Encyclopedias

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

3 human-written examples

There was also concern honours were not awarded evenly across the UK, with Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and some English regions receiving more than is proportionate for their size.

The Guardian

"What is proportionate for a repeat offender is different to what is proportionate for a first time offender".

BBC

Returning to the Belgian data protection case, Facebook has since sought to argue its tracking cookies are an important security measure for users of the site — albeit it has not provided any public comment on how it is proportionate for an online service to systematically track non-users even for, ostensibly, security purposes.

TechCrunch

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

56 human-written examples

Each of the social networks are preparing to explain how current powers are proportionate for tackling provocative material.

The Guardian

Today Harris told Mr Justice Ouseley that "it could not possibly have been proportionate for the conduct committee to have effectively adopted a 'one strike and you are out for good' approach".

The Guardian - Sport

"The fees need to be proportionate for the way that the ground transportation is being used," Fang said, adding that rental car companies need parking lots and shuttles and other infrastructure at airports.

TechCrunch

Having affirmed the position taken in Anisminic, Lord Dyson then qualified his statement by emphasizing that "the scope of judicial review should be no more (as well as no less) than is proportionate and necessary for the maintaining of the rule of law".

Wikipedia

Secondly, to lay down the provisions necessary to ensure that payments for public service are not used as a hidden and unaccountable method of covering losses caused by inefficiency, and that such support is proportionate and that 'transparent' means for essential specified services provided for society at large.

EU Parlament

The use of isofemale families to assess the genetic basis of a trait assumes that the ratio of among- to within-families variations is proportionate to the heritable variation for that trait [ 44].

BMC Evolutionary Biology

Ripa demands that the secretary of state consider whether a request for an interception is "proportionate" – a test any minister would want to apply to any request from MI5, MI6 or GCHQ.

The Guardian - Business

It cannot support an offshore regime that goes beyond what is proportionate to the requirement of detention for processing, which means they had better get on with the task.

The Guardian - Opinion

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When aiming for precision, consider using alternatives like "is appropriate for" or "is commensurate with" which are grammatically sound and widely accepted.

Common error

Avoid using "is proportionate for" in formal writing. It's often perceived as grammatically awkward. Instead, opt for more conventional phrases like "is appropriate for" or "is proportional to" to ensure clarity and correctness.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "is proportionate for" attempts to establish a relationship of balance or adequacy, but it doesn't conform to standard grammatical conventions. Ludwig AI confirms its incorrect usage, suggesting alternatives are more appropriate.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

Science

33%

News & Media

33%

Encyclopedias

33%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Wiki

0%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "is proportionate for" is generally considered grammatically incorrect in standard English. As Ludwig AI indicates, it's best to avoid this phrase in favor of more appropriate alternatives such as "is proportionate to", "is appropriate for", or "is suitable for". While the intention is to convey balance or adequacy, the non-standard construction undermines its effectiveness. Always opt for grammatically sound alternatives to maintain clarity and credibility in your writing.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

is appropriate for

Changes "proportionate" to "appropriate", focusing on suitability rather than strict balance.

is suitable for

Replaces "proportionate" with "suitable", indicating adequacy for a specific purpose.

is commensurate with

Substitutes "proportionate" with "commensurate", suggesting a comparable or corresponding relationship.

is adequate for

Emphasizes sufficiency by using "adequate" instead of "proportionate".

corresponds to

Focuses on the relationship of correspondence rather than proportionality.

is in line with

Indicates alignment or agreement instead of strict proportionality.

is adjusted to

Highlights the process of adjustment to fit a particular requirement.

is tailored to

Suggests a specific adaptation for a defined purpose.

is calibrated for

Implies precise adjustment and alignment, often in technical contexts.

is balanced with

Focuses on equilibrium and equal distribution, rather than proportionality.

FAQs

What does "is proportionate to" mean, and how does it differ from "is proportionate for"?

"Is proportionate to" indicates a direct relationship where one thing increases or decreases in relation to another. The phrase "is proportionate for" is grammatically incorrect; "is proportionate to" is the correct form.

What can I use instead of "is proportionate for"?

Since "is proportionate for" is not standard English, consider alternatives such as "is appropriate for", "is suitable for", or "is proportional to" depending on the context.

How to use "is proportional to" in a sentence?

Use "is proportional to" to show a relationship between two quantities. For example, "The effort required is proportional to the complexity of the task".

Is it ever correct to use "is proportionate for"?

No, "is proportionate for" is generally considered grammatically incorrect. Always use "is proportionate to" or rephrase with alternatives like "is appropriate for".