in commenting on

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "in commenting on" is grammatically correct and commonly used in written English.
Example: In commenting on the recent controversy surrounding the company's policies, the CEO stated, "We understand the concerns of our customers and are working to address them immediately."

✓ Grammatically correct

News & Media

Science

Encyclopedias

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

56 human-written examples

"There is probably no sense in commenting on the game after such a hammering.

Independent

In commenting on the dollar, Mr. Bernanke was making an unusual departure from custom.

The New York Times

Alex Ross missed a crucial point in commenting on today's performances of Richard Wagner's works.

The New York Times

The funny thing is that Mankiewicz, in commenting on Hearst's lack of vision, overestimated Luce's vision.

The New Yorker

In commenting on Aristotle's treatises on the natural sciences, Averroës showed considerable power of observation.

Encyclopedia Britannica

Socceroos suck", mused John of Dandenong in commenting on this article.

The Guardian - Sport

In commenting on it, he has discounted the parallels to Thornton Wilder's "Our Town".

The New York Times

I'm a bit behind the curve in commenting on the Rosenberg-Curtain piece on economics as a non-science.

The New York Times

An award-winning newspaper columnist, he is well practised in commenting on his experiences for thousands of readers each week.

The Guardian - Books

Mr. Lemons said the agency had been limited in commenting on the problem because the matter is under federal investigation.

The New York Times

Adjustment after retirement can be hard, as Angus Fraser, a former England bowler, pointed out in commenting on Lewis.

The New York Times - Sports

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using "in commenting on", ensure the subject is easily identifiable to the reader to prevent ambiguity. Clearly state the topic being commented on to enhance comprehension.

Common error

Avoid using "in commenting on" without clearly specifying what is being commented on. An unclear subject can lead to confusion and weaken the impact of your statement.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "in commenting on" functions as a prepositional phrase introducing a statement or observation related to a specific subject. It sets the context for the subsequent remark, explicitly indicating that the speaker is providing an opinion or analysis. This is supported by Ludwig's examples, which showcase its consistent use across various contexts.

Expression frequency: Very common

Frequent in

News & Media

52%

Science

22%

Encyclopedias

6%

Less common in

Wiki

5%

Formal & Business

5%

Reference

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, "in commenting on" is a grammatically correct and very common prepositional phrase used to introduce a statement or opinion related to a specific subject. According to Ludwig, this phrase is employed across a wide array of contexts, from news and media to science and encyclopedias, indicating its versatility and broad applicability. While it is suitable for neutral to formal registers, it should always be followed by a clearly defined subject to avoid ambiguity. Remember to use this phrase when you want to explicitly frame your statement as a response to a particular topic.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

regarding

Shorter, more direct preposition indicating the subject of the comment.

with respect to

A more formal way of indicating the subject of a comment or analysis.

in relation to

Focuses on the connection or relationship between the comment and the subject.

when discussing

Emphasizes the act of discussion as the context for the comment.

in reference to

Highlights that the comment is made with a specific reference point.

on the subject of

Focuses on the topic or subject being addressed in the comment.

pertaining to

Indicates that the comment is relevant or connected to a specific matter.

concerning

A direct way of stating the topic or issue that the comment relates to.

about

Simplest and most general preposition to introduce the subject.

addressing the issue of

Highlights that the comment is a direct response to a particular problem or concern.

FAQs

How can I use "in commenting on" in a sentence?

Use "in commenting on" to introduce an observation or opinion about a specific topic. For instance, "In commenting on the new policy, the manager expressed concerns".

What are some alternatives to "in commenting on"?

You can use alternatives like "regarding", "with respect to", or "concerning" to introduce your opinion.

Is there a difference between "in commenting on" and "regarding"?

"In commenting on" is more formal and explicitly indicates that you are offering an opinion. "Regarding" is more general and simply indicates the subject matter.

When is it appropriate to use "in commenting on" versus other similar phrases?

Use "in commenting on" when you want to clearly signal that you are providing an interpretation or assessment. Other phrases like "about" or "concerning" may be more suitable for simply stating a topic without necessarily implying an opinion.