To Dworkin that is no answer: if the task of a rule of recognition is to provide a way of identifying the law, the tests provided need to be complete and uncontroversial, or there is no shared way of identifying the law.
Whenever people think they disagree about how to identify the law on any point, that fact in itself demonstrates that there is nothing to disagree about: there is no law on the point at issue, if the agreed ways of identifying the law do not decide the point.
Because jihad is a pillar of Islam, and because in Islam God's word takes legal form, the classical scholars devoted considerable care to identifying the laws of jihad.
"By identifying the laws as the members of at least one non-maximal stable set, we discover how a sub-nomic fact's lawhood is fixed by the sub-nomic facts and the subjunctive facts about them" (2009, 43).
It is proposed here to identify the law of crack length evolution with a small number of parameters governing a recently presented model (Rekik and Lebon, submitted for publication) describing the interface behavior in damaged masonry.
The lawyer, Ronald G. Russo, declined to identify the law enforcement agency, but said it was conducting an inquiry, with Mr. Sprecher's cooperation, into the collapse of the $12 million show.
Some legal scholars, including some who normally lean to the left, believe the states have identified the law's weak spot and devised a credible theory for eviscerating it.
Because law is systematic (in the respect that the law gives legal institutions authority to identify the law), the courts' decisions determine legal rights and obligations.
The social conventions on the basis of which we identify the law may, but need not, contain reference to moral content as a condition of legality.
If, on the other hand, it is right to characterize an ordinary rule granting lawmaking power as a social convention that identifies the law of the community, then Dworkin's argument fails.
To identify the law of a given society we must engage in moral and political argument, for the law is whatever requirements are consistent with an interpretation of its legal practices (subject to a threshold condition of fit) that shows them to be best justified in light of the animating ideal.
