identified as to whether

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "identified as to whether" is correct and usable in written English.
It can be used when discussing the determination or classification of something based on specific criteria or conditions. Example: "The samples were identified as to whether they contained the required compounds for the experiment."

✓ Grammatically correct

Science

News & Media

Academia

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

2 human-written examples

Case submissions were not always clearly identified as to whether they were for monitoring or diagnostic purposes.

BMC Veterinary Research

Patients have been identified as to whether they were new or existing follow-up (FU) patients, whether they attended the virtual (GSMS) or consultant-led clinic, and by their gender (M=male, F=female).

BMJ Open

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

58 human-written examples

The derivative of flash point with respect to composition (solution composition effect upon flash point) can be applied to process safety design/operation in order to identify as to whether the dilution of a flammable liquid solution with water is effective in reducing the fire and explosion hazard of the solution at a specified composition.

Journal of Hazardous Materials

The task was to identify as quickly as possible whether the object was actually a gun.

BBC

Respondents' task was to identify as quickly as possible whether this shape was a circle or a square.

Huffington Post

Evaluation of the impact of educational interventions on attitudes and behaviours in professional practice settings has been identified as essential to determine whether cultural competence strategies in curricula reduce disparities in health care outcomes [ 3, 4].

BMC Medical Education

They asked a random sample of the people whom their techniques identified as paid to write for the government, whether they were doing this professionally.

The Washington Post

One key message is their lack of visibility: over a 10-year period, only 138 articles were identified as relevant to our research question of whether newsprint media represent EDs in males as 'gender appropriate'genderder anomalous' or 'gender neutral'.

BMJ Open

However, uncertainty around how Ukip supporters would vote in key Tory-Labour marginals was one of the unknown factors identified as being critical to whether Cameron's and Miliband's party would win in tens of constituencies where the outcome could be decided by a relatively small number of voters voting tactically.

The Guardian

Articles were first identified, where possible, as to whether they were primarily "descriptive" or "comparative" in their approach.

Johns Hopkins University

The respective fluorescent concentrations are detected around the cellular membrane, and pseudopods are identified and classified as to whether they are expanding or contracting.

BMC Systems Biology

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

When using "identified as to whether", ensure that the identification process is clearly defined and that the criteria for determining the outcome are explicit.

Common error

Avoid using "identified as to whether" when a simpler phrasing like "determined if" is sufficient. Overusing complex constructions can make your writing seem convoluted.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "identified as to whether" functions as a connector introducing a condition or a question. It indicates that something has been recognized or determined in relation to a specific criterion. As Ludwig AI explains, the phrase is considered correct and usable in written English.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

Science

60%

News & Media

20%

Academia

20%

Less common in

Formal & Business

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Wiki

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "identified as to whether" is grammatically correct and functions as a connector introducing a condition for classification. As Ludwig AI suggests, it is best suited for formal and scientific contexts where precise language is needed. While authoritative sources like BMC, The New York Times and The Guardian use this phrase, it's relatively rare. Consider simpler alternatives like "determined if" or "ascertained whether" depending on the level of formality required and for greater clarity in everyday conversation.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

ascertained if

Replaces "identified" with "ascertained" for a more formal tone, simplifying the "as to whether" to "if".

determined if

Focuses on the act of determination, using a direct question structure with "if".

established whether

Emphasizes the act of setting something as a certainty using "established" instead of "identified".

evaluated if

Highlights the assessment aspect, using "evaluated" to convey a careful examination.

assessed whether

Similar to evaluated, but with a slightly different nuance of appraisal.

checked to see if

Uses a more informal tone, suggesting a simple verification process.

investigated whether

Highlights a more in-depth examination or inquiry.

examined if

Focuses on careful and detailed inspection, replacing "identified" with "examined".

clarified if

Emphasizes making something clear or understandable.

confirmed whether

Highlights the process of verifying or validating something.

FAQs

How can I rephrase "identified as to whether" to sound more concise?

You can use simpler alternatives like "determined if", "established whether", or simply "identified if" depending on the context.

Is "identified as to whether" appropriate for formal writing?

Yes, "identified as to whether" is suitable for formal writing, particularly in scientific or technical contexts where precision is important. However, consider whether a more concise option like "determined if" might improve clarity.

What is the difference between "identified as to whether" and "ascertained as to whether"?

"Identified as to whether" generally means recognizing or pointing out something with regard to a condition. "Ascertained as to whether" implies a more thorough investigation to confirm something. The choice depends on the level of certainty and investigation involved.

Can I use "identified as to whether" in everyday conversation?

While grammatically correct, "identified as to whether" is more common in formal or technical writing. In everyday conversation, simpler alternatives like "found out if" or "checked if" would be more natural.