Your English writing platform
Discover LudwigSuggestions(1)
Exact(5)
Brouwer realized (Brouwer 1907, 125 128)/(Brouwer 1975, 72 73) that the hypothetical judgement seems to pose a problem for his view on logic as described above.
For what is peculiar to the hypothetical judgement, Brouwer says, is that there the priority of mathematics over logic seems to be reversed.
But, as Van Dalen also notices, it is also in effect a rejection of the hypothetical judgement in the general case where one does not know whether there is a construction for A. On this reading, Brouwer's explanation of the hypothetical judgement avoids hypothetical constructions and the concomitant use of logic by considering conditions on constructions instead of constructions themselves.
Three examples can be given that show that by the mid-1920s, Brouwer in practice worked with the hypothetical judgement and with the clause for implication in the Proof Interpretation (which was published later): an equivalence in propositional logic, the proof of the bar theorem, and his reading of ordering axioms.
Alternatively, should we adhere to the patient's previously oral or written directives, or to a hypothetical judgement of what the patient would have preferred if they had been able to describe their preferences [ 1- 3]?
Similar(55)
(However, both are hypothetical judgements in the sense that neither requires that we actually have demonstrated A).
In dealing with this objection one might appeal to Brentano's own treatment of conditional (or hypothetical) judgements.
Instead of a "chain of hypothetical judgements" that one seems to make, one is really making a chain of transformations in which from required relations (i.e., given conditions) further relations are derived.
In this study we applied a method based on judgements of hypothetical patient cases to analyse GPs' decisions about CVD risk management and their use of absolute risk.
This echoes the opinion of specialists who upgraded in 2008 a series of "Apostles" previously credited to a hypothetical "Master of Salomon's Judgement" by reassigning them to the celebrated Spanish painter.
It has been questioned whether evaluations of hypothetical scenarios accurately relate to judgements in real-life situations.
Write better and faster with AI suggestions while staying true to your unique style.
Since I tried Ludwig back in 2017, I have been constantly using it in both editing and translation. Ever since, I suggest it to my translators at ProSciEditing.

Justyna Jupowicz-Kozak
CEO of Professional Science Editing for Scientists @ prosciediting.com