had working with

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "had working with" is not correct in standard written English.
It seems to be a mix-up of verb tenses and forms, and it should be rephrased for clarity. Example: "I had been working with the team on the project before it was canceled."

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

26 human-written examples

Also tells about his famous temper and the difficulties his collaborators have had working with him.

The New Yorker

Now consider an experience I had working with a large retail bank in the early 1980s.

Harvard Business Review

Indeed she had: working with a rescue centre to trace underage soldiers and remove them from the jungle.

Independent

And I think the reason for that comes from the experience I had working with Ed Miliband.

The Guardian - Opinion

I took all the people that I had working with me – my lawyer, my agent, the president of my then-production company.

The New York Times

What is perhaps more significant than the amount of money being provided is the organization and the type of experience that W.H.O. has had working with developing countries.

The New York Times

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

34 human-written examples

He had worked with both before.

The New York Times - Sports

"He had worked with him," she said.

Independent

leaders they had worked with.

The New York Times - Health

(Diana met Princess Grace of Monaco, who had worked with Alfred Hitchcock, who had worked with Chandler).

The New York Times - Books

We had worked with him on Cars.

Huffington Post

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Avoid using the phrase "had working with" in formal writing. Instead, use grammatically correct alternatives like "had worked with" or "had experience collaborating with" for clear communication.

Common error

A common mistake is using "had working with" instead of the correct past perfect tense "had worked with". Ensure the verb form aligns with standard English grammar to avoid confusion.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "had working with" is a grammatically incorrect attempt to express a past relationship or collaboration. Ludwig AI identifies it as non-standard English, suggesting it should be avoided in formal writing.

Expression frequency: Missing

Frequent in

Science

0%

News & Media

0%

Formal & Business

0%

Less common in

Science

0%

News & Media

0%

Formal & Business

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "had working with" is grammatically incorrect and should be avoided in standard English. Ludwig AI flags it as an error, advising users to opt for grammatically sound alternatives such as "had worked with", "had experience collaborating with", or other similar phrases to clearly and accurately convey the intended meaning of past collaboration or experience. Paying attention to verb tense and grammatical structure is crucial for effective communication in both formal and informal contexts.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

had worked with

This alternative corrects the tense and grammatical structure by using the past perfect form of "work" to indicate a completed action.

had experience collaborating with

This alternative emphasizes a cooperative effort and uses the correct grammatical structure to express past experience.

had the opportunity to work with

This phrase highlights the chance or occasion to collaborate, adding a nuance of privilege or circumstance.

had been employed with

Focuses on a formal employment relationship and uses correct grammar to indicate past association.

had partnered with

This suggests a formal partnership and uses the past perfect tense to indicate a completed partnership.

had consulted with

This indicates a professional advisory relationship and employs grammatically correct past perfect tense.

had trained with

Focuses on shared training or instruction and corrects the grammatical structure to the past perfect tense.

had assisted

Highlights the act of providing assistance in the past, using correct tense and structure.

had connections with

Emphasizes existing professional network to the topic, using correct tense and structure.

had engaged with

It focus on a formal collaboration in the past, using correct tense and structure.

FAQs

How can I correct "had working with" in a sentence?

Replace "had working with" with grammatically correct alternatives like "had worked with" or "had experience collaborating with" to ensure clarity and accuracy.

What are some alternatives to "had working with" that emphasize collaboration?

Use phrases like "had the opportunity to work with" or "had partnered with" to highlight cooperative efforts in a grammatically sound way.

Is "had working with" acceptable in informal conversation?

While it might be understood in very informal contexts, it's best to avoid "had working with" altogether. Use correct grammar even in casual settings to maintain clarity and avoid misinterpretation.

What's the difference between "had working with" and "had worked with"?

"Had working with" is grammatically incorrect, while "had worked with" is the correct past perfect tense, indicating a completed action or collaboration in the past. Always use the latter for accurate and effective communication.