He reminded the jury that the complainant had admitted under oath that he had changed his story about the alleged rape, withdrawing his initial allegations that Evans had forced him into his bedroom.
And yet in previous testimony he had said under oath that she had, Mr. Brennan noted.
Before debate began Wednesday morning, Entergy said it had instructed a law firm to examine the misstatements its officials had made under oath and concluded that officials had not intended to deceive the state.
Only those athletes thought to have lied under oath have been charged.
The sext messages showed that Kilpatrick had lied under oath when he denied having an affair with his chief of staff during an investigation.
The document trove contained numerous entries from Grover and Garcia, the deputies who had testified under oath they didn't have notes about their work with informants.
The government said he did not deserve leniency because he was a "fundamentally deceptive and dishonest person" who had lied under oath in a deposition and had tried to cover up his crimes.
He had lied under oath, sued journalists he knew had been right, and ruthlessly bad-mouthed former friends who stood up to him.
Snow also said there was probable cause to believe that Arpaio intentionally failed to turn over records that he had promised, under oath, to give to the court.
Mr. Satin, who worked as an electrician, also told the judge, Magistrate Judge Henry Pitman, that he had lied under oath before a grand jury when asked if he had earned any income since retiring.
