had collaborating

USAGE SUMMARY

The phrase "had collaborating" is not correct in standard written English.
It is not a commonly used construction and may confuse readers. Example: "They had collaborating efforts on the project last year." (This should be rephrased for clarity.)

⚠ May contain grammatical issues

Wiki

Formal & Business

News & Media

Human-verified examples from authoritative sources

Exact Expressions

2 human-written examples

The program also had collaborating partners represented by: GFATM, as a main donor, WHO, UNFPA, PSI and GIZ.

Unicef

This will show support to your friend and may get him/her to remember the good times you had collaborating to build this wiki together.

WikiHow

Human-verified similar examples from authoritative sources

Similar Expressions

58 human-written examples

Some villagers had collaborated with the guerrillas.

The New York Times

It helped that the two had collaborated before.

The New York Times - Arts

Some had collaborated with the Nazis and feared retaliation.

Encyclopedia Britannica

Gordon and Intel had collaborated and rehearsed this for months.

The New Yorker

The two had collaborated with other horses, but had not had much success.

The New York Times - Sports

Valdes had collaborated with researchers in Canada and New Zealand.

Life Sciences, Society and Policy

He had collaborated with no other librettist since 1875.

Wikipedia

Soderbergh and screenwriter Scott Z. Burns had collaborated on The Informant!

Wikipedia

The HAL had collaborated with the Admiralstab since the 1890s.

Wikipedia

Expert writing Tips

Best practice

Always use the correct past participle form "collaborated" after "had". This ensures grammatical accuracy and clarity in your writing.

Common error

Avoid using the present participle "collaborating" directly after "had". The correct form is the past participle, which is "collaborated". Using the present participle creates a grammatically incorrect phrase.

Linguistic Context

The phrase "had collaborating" is intended to function as part of a verb phrase indicating a past action. However, it is grammatically incorrect as the auxiliary verb "had" requires a past participle (e.g., "collaborated"), not a present participle (e.g., "collaborating"). As Ludwig AI points out, the phrase is not correct in standard written English.

Expression frequency: Rare

Frequent in

Wiki

50%

Formal & Business

50%

News & Media

0%

Less common in

Academia

0%

Encyclopedias

0%

Science

0%

Ludwig's WRAP-UP

In summary, the phrase "had collaborating" is grammatically incorrect and should be avoided in formal and informal writing. The correct form is "had collaborated". As Ludwig AI indicates, this phrase is not standard English. When aiming to express past collaboration, use "had collaborated" or other appropriate alternatives like "had been collaborating" to ensure clarity and grammatical accuracy. Although there are a few examples of its use, they do not legitimize the construction's grammatical standing.

More alternative expressions

Phrases that express similar concepts, ordered by semantic similarity:

had collaborated

Corrects the grammatical structure by using the past participle form of the verb "collaborate".

had been collaborating

Emphasizes the ongoing nature of the collaboration in the past.

collaborated

Simplifies the phrase while maintaining the core meaning of past collaboration.

had worked together

Replaces "collaborating" with a more general term for working jointly.

had partnered

Focuses on the partnership aspect of the collaboration.

were collaborating

Emphasizes the action of collaborating was in progress at a certain point in the past.

had joined forces

Implies a combined effort towards a common goal.

had teamed up

Informal way of saying that two or more people or groups have joined together to work on something.

had cooperated

Emphasizes the cooperative nature of the work.

had contributed jointly

Highlights shared contributions to a project or effort.

FAQs

What is the correct grammatical form: "had collaborating" or "had collaborated"?

The correct grammatical form is "had collaborated". "Had" requires a past participle, and "collaborated" is the past participle of "collaborate".

What can I say instead of "had collaborating"?

You can use alternatives like "had collaborated", "had been collaborating", or simply "collaborated" depending on the context.

Is "had collaborating" ever correct?

No, "had collaborating" is not grammatically correct in standard English. The correct form is "had collaborated".

How to use "had collaborated" in a sentence?

You can use "had collaborated" to describe a past action of working together. For example: "They had collaborated on the project before it was cancelled".