The CPMC utilizes two independent Advisory Groups: the Pharmacogenomics Advisory Group PAGG), which provides guidance on PGx risk reporting, and the Informed Cohort Oversight Board (ICOB), which provides guidance on reporting to study participants of their risk for common complex diseases.
To address the unique requirements of QI research, the Standards for QI Reporting Excellence SQUIREE) group has developed detailed guidance for reporting evaluations of QI interventions. 3 The reporting guideline helps authors describe QI interventions so that they can be identified as such in electronic databases.
These recommendations aim to provide guidance for reporting results of genetic testing by biochemical genetic, cytogenetic and molecular genetic techniques.
This list is not really a tool to assess the quality of observational research but provides valuable guidance on the quality of reporting the studies.
While guidance for the developers of reporting guidelines suggests consumers might be involved as members of the development team, 11 asking consumers to evaluate existing guidelines, to our knowledge, has not been done before.
For records that provided explicit guidance on reporting of population modelling studies, the list of criteria identified was analysed using a thematic approach and the data was summarised as frequencies.
Promoting the use of the Guidance might improve the development of reporting guidelines.
In the absence of previously published reporting checklists or reporting guidance documents, a de novo list of reporting items was created by a working group comprising six health economists and one Delphi methodologist.
As neither the current PRISMA statement or the Cochrane methodological standards provide guidance about intervention reporting, authors of reviews should consider also using guidance about intervention reporting and/or a structured method of reporting intervention details, and peer reviewers and editors should be cognisant of the adequacy with which interventions are reported in reviews.
The relevant ECHA guidance document ("How to report weight of evidence") is focusing mainly on the technical issues of reporting a WoE approach in the registration dossier.
